Journals / Journal of Mosaic Research / 2026 / Sayı: 19

Distinguishing Ancient Mosaic Pavements from Modern Imitations and Forgeries: An Observation-Based Assessment

Antik Çağ Mozaik Zeminleri ile Modern İmitasyon ve Sahte Mozaiklerin Ayırt Edilmesine Yönelik Gözleme Dayalı Bir Değerlendirme

Pages
581–603
Publication Date
2026-11-12
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

The findings indicate that authenticity assessment depends not on a single criterion, but on the combined evaluation of multiple interrelated technical and observational indicators.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:This study evaluates the principal observation-based criteria that may be used to distinguish authentic ancient mosaic pavements from modern imitations and forgeries.
📊
Key Findings & Data:The study aims to assess the value of chronological and regional characteristics, material selection and use, production and laying techniques, mosaic-lifting methods, mortar layers, traces between tesserae, and surface features such as patina, soiling, and calcareous accretions as indicators of authenticity.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:The findings indicate that authenticity assessment depends not on a single criterion, but on the combined evaluation of multiple interrelated technical and observational indicators.
🔬Design:Araştırma Makalesi
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Antik Çağ · mozaik · özgünlük

Abstract

This study evaluates the principal observation-based criteria that may be used to distinguish authentic ancient mosaic pavements from modern imitations and forgeries. The study aims to assess the value of chronological and regional characteristics, material selection and use, production and laying techniques, mosaic-lifting methods, mortar layers, traces between tesserae, and surface features such as patina, soiling, and calcareous accretions as indicators of authenticity. Within this framework, the historical development of mosaic art in antiquity and its principal production techniques are briefly discussed, followed by a comparative examination of authentic ancient mosaics and modern imitations and forgeries on the basis of technical and visual evidence. The findings indicate that authenticity assessment depends not on a single criterion, but on the combined evaluation of multiple interrelated technical and observational indicators. The study presents a methodological framework for the accurate identification, documentation, and conservation of ancient mosaics, while also supporting the detection of imitations and forgeries and contributing to assessment processes aimed at the protection of cultural heritage.

Özet

Öz Bu çalışma, özgün Antik Çağ mozaik zeminleri ile modern imitasyon ve sahte mozaiklerin ayırt edilmesinde başvurulabilecek gözleme dayalı temel ölçütleri değerlendirmektedir. Araştırmanın amacı, özgünlük değerlendirmesinde dönemsel ve bölgesel özelliklerin, malzeme kullanımının, üretim ve döşeme tekniklerinin, mozaik kaldırma yöntemlerinin, harç tabakalarının, tessera aralarındaki izlerin ve yüzeyde oluşan patina, kir ve kalker birikimlerinin ayırt edici değerini ortaya koymaktır. Bu kapsamda, mozaik sanatının Antik Çağ’daki tarihsel gelişimi ve başlıca yapım teknikleri kısaca ele alınmış ve özgün Antik Çağ mozaikleri ile modern imitasyon ve sahte örnekler teknik ve görsel veriler doğrultusunda karşılaştırmalı olarak incelenmiştir. İncelemeler sonucunda, özgünlük değerlendirmesinin tek bir kritere değil, birbiriyle ilişkili çok yönlü teknik ve gözlemsel verilerin birlikte ele alınmasına bağlı olduğu anlaşılmıştır. Çalışma, Antik Çağ mozaiklerinin doğru tanımlanması, belgelenmesi ve korunmasına yönelik yöntemsel bir çerçeve sunmakta ve aynı zamanda imitasyon ve sahte örneklerin tespitini destekleyerek kültürel mirasın korunmasına yönelik değerlendirme süreçlerine katkıda bulunmaktadır.

🔖

Cite This Article

Aldemir, C., Çelik, Ö. (2026). Distinguishing Ancient Mosaic Pavements from Modern Imitations and Forgeries: An Observation-Based Assessment. Journal of Mosaic Research, Sayı: 19, 581–603. https://doi.org/10.26658/jmr.2072529

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (35)

  1. Andreescu-Treadgold 2013 I. Andreescu-Treadgold, “The Christ Head at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, the Apse in the Bode Museum, Berlin, and Other Fake Mosaics”, C. Entwistle - L. James (eds.), New Light on Old Glass: Recent Research on Byzantine Mosaics and Glass, London, 271-290.
  2. Avi-Yonah 1975a M. Avi-Yonah, Ancient Mosaics, London.
  3. Avi-Yonah 1975b M. Avi-Yonah, The Art of Mosaics, Minneapolis.
  4. Ball et al. 2024 R. J. Ball - M. P. Ansell - T. B. Su-Cadirci - V. A. Baki - P. J. Fletcher - A. Lichtenberger - R. Raja - W. Wootton, “Analysis of Mosaic Mortars from the Roman, Byzantine and Early Islamic Periods Sourced from Gerasa’s Northwest Quarter”, Heritage Science 12, 168.
  5. Becker - Kondoleon 2005 L. Becker - C. Kondoleon, The Arts of Antioch: Art Historical and Scientific Approaches to Roman Mosaics and a Catalogue of the Worcester Art Museum Antioch Collection, Princeton.
  6. Belis 2016 A. Belis, Roman Mosaics in the J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles.
  7. Bowersock 2006 G. W. Bowersock, Mosaics as History: The Near East from Late Antiquity to Islam, Cambridge, Massachusetts-London.
  8. Carmo 2017 F. Carmo, “Rome: Economic Change in the 2nd Century BC - The Context of Mosaic as a Luxury Product”, JMR 10, 101-116.
  9. Cimok 2005 F. Cimok, Mosaics of Antioch, İstanbul.
  10. Chlouveraki - Politis 2003 S. N. Chlouveraki - K. D. Politis, “The Documentation and Conservation of the Nave Mosaic in the Basilica of Agios Lot at Deir 'Ain 'Abata, Jordan”, D. Michaelides (ed.), Mosaics Make a Site: The Conservation in situ of Mosaics on Archaeological Sites, Proceedings of the VIth Conference of the International Committee for the Conservation of Mosaics, Rome, 149-156.
  11. Cura 2021 M. Cura, “Farklı Bir Mozaik Kaldırma Tekniği - Zarflama (Controcalco)”, Lycus Dergisi 3, 77-91.
  12. Dunbabin 1978 K. M. D. Dunbabin, The Mosaics of Roman North Africa: Studies in Iconography and Patronage, Oxford Monographs on Classical Archaeology, Oxford.
  13. Dunbabin 1999 K. M. D. Dunbabin, Mosaics of the Greek and Roman World, Cambridge.
  14. Ekincioğlu vd. 2018 G. Ekincioğlu - Z. Başıbüyük - A. Gölbaş - İ. Kaydu Akbudak, “Geçmişten Günümüze Doğaltaş Mozaik Sanatı ve Geleceğe Aktarılması”, JIA: International Journal of Interdisciplinary and Intercultural Art 3, 4, 81-91.
  15. Er 2017 Y. Er, Klasik Arkeoloji Sözlüğü, Ankara.
  16. Fragata et al. 2021 A. Fragata - J. Ribeiro - C. Candeias - A. Velosa - F. Rocha, “Archaeological and Chemical Investigation on the High Imperial Mosaic Floor Mortars of the Domus Integrated in the Museum of Archaeology D. Diogo de Sousa, Braga, Portugal”, Appl. Sci. 11, 8267.
  17. Kaplan vd. 2017 Z. Kaplan - B. İpekoğlu - H. Böke, “Roma Dönemi Döşeme Mozaiklerinin Yapım Tekniği ve Malzeme Özellikleri”, Uluslararası Katılımlı 6. Tarihi Yapıların Korunması ve Güçlendirilmesi Sempozyumu, Trabzon, 237-245.
  18. Kipfer 2000 B. A. Kipfer, Encyclopedic Dictionary of Archaeology, New York.
  19. Kondoleon 2001 C. Kondoleon, “ The Roman House”, C. Kondoleon (ed.), Antioch: The Lost Ancient City, Princeton, 169-180.
  20. Ling 1998 R. Ling, Ancient Mosaics, Princeton.
  21. Michel - Friedrich 2020 C. Michel - M. Friedrich, “Fakes and Forgeries of Written Artefacts: An Introduction”, C. Michel - M. Friedrich (eds.), Fakes and Forgeries of Written Artefacts from Ancient Mesopotamia to Modern China, Berlin-Boston, 1-22.
  22. Muşkara 2023 Ü. Muşkara, “Arkeolojide Malzeme Analizi ve Sahte Eserlerin Belirlenmesi”, Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi 25, 4, 1530-1553.
  23. Nardi 2003 R. Nardi, “The Treatment of Mosaics in situ”, D. Michaelides (ed.), Mosaics Make a Site: The Conservation in situ of Mosaics on Archaeological Sites, Proceedings of the VIth Conference of the International Committee for the Conservation of Mosaics, 1996, Rome, 187-202.
  24. Papiu - Suciu 2017 G. A. Papiu - N. Suciu, “Arts and Technology – Mosaic New Techniques and Procedures”, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 200, 1-7.
  25. Parrish 2017 D. Parrish, “East versus West in the Iconography of Roman Mosaics: Selected Examples of Shared Themes”, JMR 10, 259-283.
  26. Parrot 1961 A. Parrot, Sumer: The Dawn of Art, New York.
  27. Poeschke 2010 J. Poeschke, Italian Mosaics, 300-1300, New York-London.
  28. Polat 2002 Y. Polat, “Antik Mozaiklerin Restorasyonu Konservasyonu ve Kaldırılması”, Anadolu Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Dergisi 1, 3, 287-305.
  29. Scheibelreiter 2007 V. Scheibelreiter, “Römische Mosaiken in Westkleinasien”, M. Meyer (ed.), Neue Zeiten – Neue Sitten. Zu Rezeption und Integration römischen und italischen Kulturguts in Kleinasien, Vienna, 155-169.
  30. Şener 2012 Y. S. Şener, “Arkeolojik Alanda In situ (Yerinde) Mozaik Koruma Yöntemleri”, JMR 5, 201-220.
  31. Takács 2001 S. A. Takács, “Pagan Cults at Antioch”, C. Kondoleon (ed.), Antioch: The Lost Ancient City, Princeton, 198-216.
  32. Vitr. Vitruvius, Mimarlık Üzerine On Kitap, S. Güven (çev.), İstanbul, 1990.
  33. Westgate 2012 R. C. Westgate, “Mosaics, Roman Empire”, R. S. Bagnall - K. Brodersen - C. B. Champion - A. Erskine - S. R. Huebner (eds.), The Encyclopedia of Ancient History, Oxford, 4598-4602.
  34. Young 1957 R. S. Young, “Gordion 1956: Preliminary Report”, AJA 61, 319-331.
  35. Young 1963 J. L. Young, Mosaics: Principles and Practice, New York.