Journals / Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul / 2023 / Sayı: 71

Transforming the Judiciary into the Rulers’ Proxies: The Case of Hagia Sophia

Pages
51–62
Publication Date
2023-02-06
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

Our analysis reveals the political decisions that would possibly be the subject of criticism by domestic opponents and the international community to have been eliminated by referring the issue to the packed courts in order to avoid all undesired consequences.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:This article examines from a critical perspective the judgment of the Turkish Council of State (Danıştay) in 2020, which invalidated the executive decision of 1934 regarding the designation of Hagia Sophia in Istanbul as a museum.
📊
Key Findings & Data:Moreover, the developments before and after the decision demonstrate this judgement to be a product of a non-judicial motivation.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:Our analysis reveals the political decisions that would possibly be the subject of criticism by domestic opponents and the international community to have been eliminated by referring the issue to the packed courts in order to avoid all undesired consequences.
🔬Design:Research Article
📍Scope:2020 Verileri
⚙️Variables:Rule of Law · Judicial Independence · Court Packing

Abstract

This article examines from a critical perspective the judgment of the Turkish Council of State (Danıştay) in 2020, which invalidated the executive decision of 1934 regarding the designation of Hagia Sophia in Istanbul as a museum. We argue that Council of State did not really perform adjudication of a legal dispute in this case, but rather functioned as a proxy of the executive power for particular reasons. As a matter of fact, we argue the justifications regarding the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and the right to property on which the decision was based to be a falsification. Moreover, the developments before and after the decision demonstrate this judgement to be a product of a non-judicial motivation. Lastly, the sequence of political actions regarding the conversion of several other museums into mosques that have been observed in Turkey over the last ten years implies the non-judicial dynamics behind the Council of State’s decision regarding Hagia Sophia. Our analysis reveals the political decisions that would possibly be the subject of criticism by domestic opponents and the international community to have been eliminated by referring the issue to the packed courts in order to avoid all undesired consequences.

🔖

Cite This Article

BAHÇECİ, B., YOLCU, S. (2023). Transforming the Judiciary into the Rulers’ Proxies: The Case of Hagia Sophia. Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, Sayı: 71, 51–62. https://ajindex.com/articles/880909

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (5)

  1. Al, S, “Hagia Sophia in Turkey’s culture wars”, Le Monde Diplomatique, 3 August 2020, https:// mondediplo.com/outsidein/hagia-sophia Aykaç, P, “Contesting the Byzantine Past: Four Hagia Sophias as Ideological Battlegrounds of Architectural Conservation in Turkey”, Heritage & Society 11:2 (2018), 151-178. Bakan Albayrak’tan Ayasofya Paylaşımı, Hürriyet, 10.07.2020 https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/ ekonomi/son-dakika-bakan-albayrak-kazanimlarimizi-koruyarak-bu-surecten-guclenerek- cikacagiz-41561700 (accessed on March 25, 2021).
  2. Berkley Forum, Hagia Sophia: From Museum to Mosque, July 17, 2020, https://berkleycenter. georgetown.edu/posts/hagia-sophia-from-museum-to-mosque Biden statement on calling “Turkish President Erdogan to reverse his recent decision to convert the Hagia Sophia to a mosque”, https://joebiden.com/2020/10/06/tensions-between-greece-and- turkey-statement-by-vice-president-joe-biden/ Çalı, B, Durmuş, B, “Judicial Self-Government as Experimental Constitutional Politics: The Case of Turkey”, German Law Journal, 19 (7) (2018): 1671-1706.
  3. Çelik, D B, “16 Nisan Anayasa Değişikliği ve Yeni Hâkimler ve Savcılar Kurulu Üzerine Bir Değerlendirme”, Ankara Üniversitesi SBF Dergisi 73 (2018) 1057-1094. EU ministers chide Turkey over Hagia Sophia, https://www.dw.com/en/turkey-haghia-sofia- european-union/a-54165074 Eyice, S, https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/ayasofya-camii--trabzon
  4. Goodyear, M P, “Heaven or Earth: The Hagia Sophia Re-Conversion, Turkish and International Law, and the Special Case of Universal Religious Sites”, UCLA Journal of Islamic & Near Eastern Law, Forthcoming Fall 2021, https://ssrn.com/abstract=3680139 Hagia Sophia: UNESCO deeply regrets the decision of the Turkish authorities, https://en.unesco. org/news/unesco-statement-hagia-sophia-istanbul Herrin, J, Opinion, “Converting Hagia Sophia into a Mosque Is an Act of Cultural Cleansing”, Washington Post 15 July 2020, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/07/15/ converting-hagia-sophia-into-mosque-is-an-act-cultural-cleansing/ Hilafetin İlga ve Hanedan-ı Osmaninin Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Memaliki Haricine Çıkarılmasına Dair Kanun, Law no 431, Enacted on 03.03.1924, Resmi Gazete 06.03.1924/63 Kısakürek, N F, “Ayasofya” Büyük Doğu (1959) 1 Kustra-Rogatka, A, Populist but not Popular: The abortion judgment of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal, VerfBlog, 2020/11/03, https://verfassungsblog.de/populist-but-not-popular/, DOI: 10.17176/20201103-235627-0
  5. Landau D, Dixon, R, “Abusive Judicial