Journals / Praksis / 2009 / Sayı: 21

Some observations and considerations on ergenekon trials and left wing approaches

Ergenekon davaları ve solun tutumu üzerine bazı gözlem ve değiniler

Journal
Praksis
Pages
77–112
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

Although socialist left’s approach, based on a generalised analysis of class struggle, methodologically underlines a common and tactical ‘third party’ policy, particularist readings of class struggle bear the potential to contemplate different analyses such as viewing the process as an internal conflict of the bourgeoisie or perceiving AKP governments as a long-term hegemonic project of the capitalist class.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:Polarisation between Turkish bourgeois political forces that has deepened during the time of Justice and Development Party (AKP) governments is continuing with rendering Ergenekon trials as its subject.
📊
Key Findings & Data:This article will provide a concise overview of the judicial process and assess various left wing stances that tend to side with respective parties of the procedure, and in particular, will analyse the socialist left’s independent position with its pretexts.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:Although socialist left’s approach, based on a generalised analysis of class struggle, methodologically underlines a common and tactical ‘third party’ policy, particularist readings of class struggle bear the potential to contemplate different analyses such as viewing the process as an internal conflict of the bourgeoisie or perceiving AKP governments as a long-term hegemonic project of the capitalist class.
🔬Design:Research Article
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:ABD · USA

Abstract

Polarisation between Turkish bourgeois political forces that has deepened during the time of Justice and Development Party (AKP) governments is continuing with rendering Ergenekon trials as its subject. This article will provide a concise overview of the judicial process and assess various left wing stances that tend to side with respective parties of the procedure, and in particular, will analyse the socialist left’s independent position with its pretexts. By a factual view, it can be observed that ‘paramilitary gangs’ and ‘coup attempts’ are prosecuted in the course of this unfinished process of investigations and trials. Nevertheless, it becomes obvious that the process goes beyond prosecution, in order to form a sort of ‘martial law’ and target all opponents of AKP as part of a process of political and social reconstruction. Liberal left that views AKP’s electoral victory as a ‘conservative revolution’ deems AKP governments’ main goal as weakening the military mandate through prospects of European Union membership and democratisation and consider Ergenekon trials as a part of these prospects. Nationalist left, on the other hand, is arguing that AKP governments’ major direction is determined by regional interests of the USA and the project of a moderate Islamic state, considering the Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) as the guarantor of the Republic’s democratic achievements, secularism in particular, against AKP governments’ moves to deteriorate them, therefore, reaching the conclusion that TSK should be kept exempt from criticism. The proponents of this current view Ergenekon trials as an assault to destroy TSK and republican forces. According to the socialist left, both approaches lack an analysis of class struggles and do not harbour the potential to give way to political consequences on behalf of workers and the oppressed. Although socialist left’s approach, based on a generalised analysis of class struggle, methodologically underlines a common and tactical ‘third party’ policy, particularist readings of class struggle bear the potential to contemplate different analyses such as viewing the process as an internal conflict of the bourgeoisie or perceiving AKP governments as a long-term hegemonic project of the capitalist class.

Keywords
🔖

Cite This Article

MISIR, M. B. (2009). Some observations and considerations on ergenekon trials and left wing approaches. Praksis, Sayı: 21, 77–112. https://ajindex.com/articles/303074

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (24)

  1. Agamben, G. (2008) Olağanüstü Hal, çev. Kemal Atakay, İstanbul:
  2. Varlık. Akınsoy, A. (2003) “23. Yılında 12 Eylül: Sınıf Mücadelesinde Kırılma”, Marksist Tutum, http://www.marksist. com/akin_erensoy/23_yilinda_12_eylul_sinif_mucadelesinde_kirilma.htm, indirilme tarihi: 10.10.2009.
  3. Birand, M. A. (1986) 12 Eylül Saat: 04.00, İstanbul:
  4. Karacan. Belge, M. (2009) “1 Mayıs ama Taksim’de”, Taraf, 02.05.2009.
  5. Çeçen, A. (1997)
  6. Ulusal Sol, İstanbul:
  7. Çağdaş. Çeçen, M. (2008) “Gerçek ve Görev” Sosyalist Emek, (Nisan 2008): 12-13.
  8. Dinler, D. (2003) “Türkiye’de Güçlü Devlet Geleneği Tezinin Bir Eleştirisi” Praksis (9): 17-54.
  9. Düzel, N. (2008) Murat Belge ile Söyleşi: “2009’da Kıyamet Gibi Kan Akacaktı!” Taraf, 28-29 Ocak 2008, http:// www.savaskarsitlari.org/arsiv.asp?ArsivTipID=1&ArsivAnaI D=43479, indirilme tarihi: 06.10.2009
  10. Dündar, C. ve C. Kazdağlı (1997)
  11. Ergenekon, Ankara:
  12. İmge. Eroğul, C. (1974) “Marksist Devlet Kuramı Hakkında Bir Not” A.Ü. Siyasal Bilgiler Fakültesi Dergisi, Cilt:29 (1): 113- 123. Evren, S. (2007) “Kırmızı Cuma’nın Faili 17 Yaşında mıdır?” Siyasi Gazete, (Şubat 2007): 17-18.
  13. Evren, S. (2008) “Herkes Yerli Yerinde: Savcı Hariç (1) ve (2)”, www.bianet.org, indirilme tarihleri: 22.03.2008 ve 29.03.2008
  14. Fırat, H. (2009) “Burjuva Gericiliğinin İç Dalaşması ve Devrimci Sınıf Çizgisi: Rejim Krizinde Yeni Safha”, http://www.kizilbayrak.net/makaleler-yazarlar/haber/arsiv/2008/04/01/ browse/10/artikel/177/ rejim-krizinde.html?tx_ttnews%5Bswords%5D=Sol%20hareket%2C%20Parti%20ve%20yeni%20 d%F6nem&cHash=294a52494d, indirilme tarihi: 10.10.2009.
  15. Gerger, H. (2008) “ABD Terbiye Ediyor” Mavi Defter, genel ağ dergisi, 08.08.2008, http://www.mavidefter.org/ index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=99:abd-terbiye-ediyor&catid=51:halukgerger&Item id=89, indirilme tarihi: 10.10.2009.
  16. Güler, A. (2008) “Amerikan Barışına Doğru: Sarsıla Sarsıla”, Ergenekon ve Sosyalistler (der: Merdan Yanardağ) içinde ss. 15-38, İstanbul:
  17. Siyah-Beyaz. İnsel, A. (2009) “Ergenekon Davaları Üzerinden Zihniyet Polisliği Yapmak” Birikim, (241): 3-7.
  18. Kalkan, E. (2006) Katille Buluşma Bir Jitem Dosyası: Musa Anter Cinayeti, İstanbul:
  19. Güncel. Kılıç, E. (2009)
  20. JİTEM, İstanbul:
  21. Timaş. Kürkçü, E. (2004) “Üçüncü Bir Kutup Gerek” Siyasi Gazete, (Ocak 2004): 3-4.
  22. Kürkçü, E. (2008) “Üçüncü Bir Kutup Var” Radikal İki, 27.07.2008.
  23. Kürkçü, E. (2009) “Ergenekon Solda Safl aşmanın Bağlamı Değil Yansısı” Radikal, 04.05.2009.
  24. Kürkçü, E. (2009b) “12 Eylül’den Sonra Sol” 2009 Karaburun Bilim Kongresi’nde y