Journals / İstanbul Üniversitesi Sosyoloji Dergisi / 2024 / Cilt: 44 Sayı: 2

Can Disasters Be Unnatural? A Sociological Discussion on the “Naturalness” of Disasters

Afetler Doğal Olmayabilir mi?: Afetlerin “Doğallığı” Üzerine Sosyolojik Bir Tartışma

Fatma Levent(Anadolu Üniversitesi, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Sosyoloji Anabilim Dalı)0000-0002-1683-3539
Temmuz Gönç Şavran(Anadolu Üniversitesi, Edebiyat Fakültesi, Sosyoloji Bölümü)0000-0003-0561-4661
Pages
765–793
Publication Date
2024-12-31
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

In this framework, it is important to approach the use of the term “natural disaster” critically as it carries certain risks.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:Disaster is attracting more and more attention as an interdisciplinary field of study.
📊
Key Findings & Data:In recent years, both the assertion that disasters are not a natural phenomenon but a social one and the criticism of this assertion have become more widespread.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:In this framework, it is important to approach the use of the term “natural disaster” critically as it carries certain risks.
🔬Design:Araştırma Makalesi
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Doğal afet · Afet sosyolojisi · Kırılganlık

Abstract

Disaster is attracting more and more attention as an interdisciplinary field of study. In recent years, both the assertion that disasters are not a natural phenomenon but a social one and the criticism of this assertion have become more widespread. This article is a compilation study prepared to discuss these claims and to show how the interpretations, meanings, and connotations associated with disasters direct social dynamics from the perspective of critical sociology. The study highlights how concepts are constructed within discourses and used to construct certain truths, how definitions of disaster have changed based on the hazards paradigm, the vulnerability paradigm, and critical approaches, and discusses the risks and conceptual confusion that can be created by using the concept of “natural disaster”. In essence, the blaming of nature solely for disasters removes human influence from the equation and promotes the idea that humans are at war with nature. This reinforces the belief that human beings will fail in the face of nature no matter what they do, but it also prepares the ground for the implementation of disaster policies and laws that favour the interests of one group while ignoring others. The concepts employed contribute to the reinforcement of this ground, even if the individuals using them are unaware of it. The discourse produces information on which population requires assistance and is at risk, as well as which form of assistance will be provided to whom. However, these processes are not independent of power. Social institutions shape discourse by framing it with ideology and reproducing it. Thus, the problematic use of language within the discourse that points to a particular paradigm can legitimise one type of knowledge and interest while rendering the other invisible. In this framework, it is important to approach the use of the term “natural disaster” critically as it carries certain risks.

Özet

Disiplinler arası bir çalışma konusu olarak afet giderek daha fazla ilgi görmektedir. Son yıllarda hem afetin doğal değil toplumsal bir olgu olduğu yönündeki iddialar hem de buna yönelik eleştiriler yaygınlaşmaktadır. Bu makale bu iddiaları tartışmak ve eleştirel sosyoloji perspektifinden hareketle afete ilişkin yorum, anlam ve çağrışımların toplumsal dinamikleri nasıl yönlendirdiğini göstermek amacıyla hazırlanmış bir derleme çalışmasıdır. Çalışmada kavramların söylemler çerçevesinde inşa edildiği ve belirli hakikatleri oluşturmak için kullandığı vurgulanmakta, tehlikeler paradigması, kırılganlık paradigması ve eleştirel yaklaşımlardan yola çıkarak afete ilişkin tanımların nasıl değiştiğine değinilmekte ve “doğal afet” kavramını kullanmanın yaratabileceği riskler ve kavram karmaşası tartışılmaktadır. Afetlerden yalnızca doğayı sorumlu tutmak insanın doğayla savaş hâlinde olduğu ve insanın doğa karşısında ne yaparsa yapsın başarısız olacağı düşüncesini güçlendirir, bu düşünce bir grubun çıkarını gözetirken diğerini görmezden gelen afet politika ve yasaları için de zemin hazırlar. Hangi nüfusun yardıma muhtaç ve risk altında olduğu, kime hangi yardımların yapılacağı tartışılırken kullanılan kavramlar bu zemini güçlendirebilir. Toplumsal kurumlar söylemi ideolojiyle çerçeveleyerek şekillendirip ideolojiyi yeniden ürettiği için belirli bir paradigmaya işaret eden söylem içindeki dilin problemli kullanımı bir tür bilgiyi ve çıkarı meşru kılarken diğerini görünmez hâle getirebilir. Bu çerçevede “doğal afet” kavramını kullanmak da benzer riskleri taşıdığı için bu kavrama eleştirel yaklaşmak gerekmektedir.

🔖

Cite This Article

Levent, F., Şavran, T. G. (2024). Can Disasters Be Unnatural? A Sociological Discussion on the “Naturalness” of Disasters. İstanbul Üniversitesi Sosyoloji Dergisi, Cilt: 44 Sayı: 2, 765–793. https://doi.org/10.26650/SJ.2024.44.2.0020

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (94)

  1. Abiona, O., & Foureaux Koppensteiner, M. (2018). The impact of household shocks on domestic violence: evidence from Tanzania. IZA Institute for Labor Economics, 11992. google scholar
  2. Agnew, D. C., Lee, W. H. K., Kanamori, H., Jennings, P. C., & Kisslinger, C. (2002). History of seismology. International Handbook of Earthquake and Engineering Seismology, 81(A), 3-11. google scholar
  3. Aguillon-Lombana, A., & Serna-Dimas, A. (2023). Memory and socio-natural disaster. a global look at social studies of memory and ıts relation with socio-natural disasters between 2000 and 2020. Cuadernos de Geografa: Revista Colombiana de Geografa, 32(1), 3-18. google scholar
  4. Anderson, W. A. (1965). Some observations on a disaster subculture: the organizational response ofCincinnati, Ohio to the 1964 flood. Disaster Research Center Research Report. google scholar AragOn-Durand, F. D. J. (2009). Unpacking the social construction of’natural’disaster through policy discourses and institutional responses in Mexico: the case ofChalco Valley’s floods, State of Mexico (Doctoral dissertation, UCL University College London). google scholar
  5. Bahmani, H., & Zhang, W. (2022). Why Do Communities Recover Differently after Socio-Natural Disasters? Pathways to Comprehensive Success of Recovery Projects Based on Bam’s (Iran) Neighborhoods’ Perspective. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19 (2), 678. google scholar
  6. Barton, A. H. (1969). Communities in disaster: A sociological analysis of collective stress situations, Doubleday, New York. google scholar
  7. Ball, N. (1975). The myth of natural disasters. The Ecologist, 5(10), 368-369. google scholar
  8. Blaikie, P., Cannon, T., Davis, I., & Wisner, B. (1994). At Risk: Natural Hazards, People’s Vulnerability and Disasters. London: Routledge. google scholar
  9. Bankoff, G. (2001). Rendering the world unsafe: ‘‘Vulnerability’’ as western discourse. Disasters, 25(1), 19-35. google scholar
  10. Bankoff, G., Frerks, G., Hilhorst, T., & Hilhorst, D. (Eds.). (2004). Mapping vulnerability: disasters, development, and people. New York: Routledge. google scholar
  11. Boin, A., McConnell, A., & ‘t Hart, P. (Eds.). (2008). Governing after crisis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press google scholar
  12. Bosher, L.S. (2008). The need for built-in resilience, In Bosher L.S. (Ed.), Hazards and the built environment: Attaining built-in resilience (pp. 3-19) London: Taylor & Francis. google scholar
  13. Brookfield, H. (1999). Environmental damage: Distinguishing human from geophysical causes. Global Environmental Change Part B: Environmental Hazards. 1(1): 3-11. google scholar
  14. Buckle, P. (2005). Mandated definitions, local knowledge and complexity. In R. W. Perry & E. L. Quarantelli (Eds.), What is a disaster: New answers to old questions (pp. 173-200). Philadelphia: Xlibris Publishers. google scholar
  15. Bullard, R. D. (1994). Overcoming Racism in Environmental Decisionmaking. Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 36 (4): 10-44. google scholar
  16. Burton, I., Kates, R.W., & White, G.F. (1978) The environment as hazard. New York: Oxford University Press. google scholar
  17. Button, G. (2016). Disaster Culture: Knowledge and Uncertainty in the Wake of Human and Environmental Catastrophe. Routledge, Oxfordshire, UK. google scholar
  18. Cannon, T. (1994). Vulnerability analysis and the explanation of ‘natural’disasters. Disasters, Development And Environment, 1, 13-30. google scholar
  19. Castano, J. G. (2019). The Borders of Tropicality. Refuge: Canada’s Journal on Refugees, 35(1), 18-31. google scholar
  20. Chakraborty, J., Collins, T., Montgomery, M., & Grineski, S. (2014). Social and spatial inequities in exposure to flood risk in Miami, Florida, Natural Hazards Review, 15(3), 152-157. google scholar
  21. Chmutina, K., Sadler, N., von Meding, J., & Abukhalaf, A. H. I. (2021), How the english language dominates disaster research and practice, E-International Relations, ISSN 2053-8626. doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.12007.57761 google scholar
  22. Chmutina, K., & von Meding, J. (2019). A dilemma of language:“Natural disasters” in academic literature. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 10, 283-292. google scholar
  23. Chmutina, K., von Meding, J., & Bosher, L. S. (2019). Language matters: Dangers of the “natural disaster” misnomer. Global Assessment Report on Disaster Risk Reduction. google scholar
  24. Cisin, I. H., & Clark, W. B. (1962). The methodological challenge of disaster research. In G. Baker & D. Chapman (Eds.), Man and society in disaster (pp. 23-54). New York: Basic Books. google scholar
  25. Clarke, L. (1988). Politics and Bias in Risk Assessment. The Social Science Journal, 25 (2): 155-165. google scholar
  26. Clarke, L., & Short, Jr, J. F. (1993). Social organization and risk: Some Current Controversies. Annual Review of Sociology, 19 (1): 375-399. google scholar
  27. Comfort, L., Tekin, A., Pretto, E., Kirimli, B., & Anges, D. (1998), ‘Time, knowledge, and action: The effects of trauma upon community capacity for action’, International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters, 16(1), pp. 88-89. google scholar
  28. Donner, W., & Havidan, R. (2008). Population composition, migration, and inequality: The influence of demographic changes on disaster risk and vulnerability. Social Forces, 87(2), 1089-1114. google scholar
  29. Doocy, S., Daniels, A., Murray, S., & Kirsch, T, D. (2013). The human impact of floods: a historical review of events 1980-2009 and systematic literature review. PLOS Currents Disasters, 1. http:// currents.plos.org/ disasters/index.html%3Fp=6695.html. google scholar
  30. Drabek, T. E. 1986. Human system response to disaster: An inventory of sociological findings. London: Springer-verlag. google scholar
  31. Dynes, R. R. (1993). Disaster reduction: The importance of adequate assumptions about social organization. Sociological spectrum, 13(1), 175-192. google scholar
  32. Enarson, E., & Morrow, B. H. (1998). “Why gender? Why women? An introduction to women and disaster”. In The gendered terrain of disaster: Through Women’s Eyes. Westport, CT: Praeger. google scholar
  33. Foucault, M. (2014). Bilginin arkeolojisi (Çev. V. Urhan). İstanbul: Ayrıntı Yayınları. google scholar
  34. Fothergill, A., Maestas, E. G., & Darlington, J. D. (1999). Race, Ethnicity and Disasters in the United States: A Review of the Literature. Disasters, 23 (2), 156-173. google scholar
  35. Fritz, C. E. (1961). Disaster. In R. K. Merton & R. A. Nisbet (Eds.), Contemporary Social Problems: An Introduction to the Sociology of Deviant Behavior and Social Disorganization. (pp. 651-694). New York; Burlingame; Harcourt, Brace & World. google scholar
  36. Fritz, C. E., & Williams, H. B. (1957). The human being in disasters: A research perspective. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 309 (1), 42-51. google scholar
  37. Gaillard, J. C., & Mercer, J. (2012). From knowledge to action: Bridging gaps in disaster risk reduction. Progress in Human Geography, 37(1), 93-114. google scholar
  38. Gilbert, C. (1998). Studying disaster. In E. L. Quarantelli (Ed.), What is a disaster: Perspectives on the question (pp. 11-18). London: Routledge. google scholar
  39. Gould, K.A., Garcia, M.M., & Remes, J.A.C. (2016). Beyond ‘‘natural-disasters-are-not-natural’’: The work of state and natüre after the 2010 earthquake in Chile. Journal of Political Ecology. 23(1), 93-114. google scholar
  40. Helsloot, I., & Ruitenberg, A. (2004). Citizen response to disasters: A survey of literature and some practical implications. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 12(3), 98-111. google scholar
  41. Herzog, R. J. (2007). A model of natural disaster administration: Naming and framing theory and reality. Administrative Theory & Praxis, 29(4), 586-604. google scholar
  42. Jackson, R., Fitzpatrick, D., & Man Singh, P. (2016). Building back right: Ensuring equality in land rights and reconstruction in Nepal. Oxfam International. google scholar
  43. Jaime, D., Martmez, P., Contreras, D., Bonacic, C., & Marin, M. (2023). Volunteers’ capabilities and their perceived satisfaction and performance in volunteering tasks during socio-natural disasters. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 85, 103510. google scholar
  44. Kelman, I. (2010). Natural disasters do not exist (natural hazards do not exist either) Version 3, 9 July 2010 (Version 1 was 26 July 2007). Downloaded from: https://www.ilankelman.org/ miscellany/NaturalDisasters.doc google scholar
  45. Kreps, G. A. (1985). Disaster and the social order. Sociological Theory, 3(1), 49-64. google scholar
  46. Kreps, G.A. (1998). Disaster as systemic event and social catalyst: A clarification of subject matter. In E.L. Quarantelli, (Ed.), What is a disaster: Perspectives on the question (pp. 31-55). New York and London: Routledge. google scholar
  47. Kumagai, Y., Edwards, J., & Carroll, M. S. (2006). Why are natural disasters not “natural” for victims?. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 26(1), 106-119. google scholar
  48. Kuran, C. H. A., Morsut, C., Kruke, B. I., Krüger, M., Segnestam, L., Orru, K.,. & Torpan, S. (2020). Vulnerability and vulnerable groups from an intersectionality perspective. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 50, 101826. google scholar
  49. Martin, J. R., & Veel, R. (2005). Discourses of science. In Reading science (pp. 13-24). New York: Routledge. google scholar
  50. Lindell, M. K., & Perry, R. W. (2004). Communicating environmental risk in multiethnic communities. Sage publications. Thousand Oaks. google scholar
  51. Lizardo, O. (2010). Culture and stratification. In: Handbook of cultural sociology. Hall John R., Grindstaff Laura, Lo Ming-Cheng. (Eds.). Routledge; New York: 305-15. google scholar
  52. Mela, A., Mugnano, S., & Olori, D. (2017). Socio-natural disaster, resilience and vulnerability: The territorial perspective in italian current debate. Sociologia Urbana e Rurale. google scholar
  53. Mileti, D. S. (1999). Disasters by design. Washington, DC, USA: John Henry Press. google scholar
  54. Miskimmon, A., O’Loughlin, B., & Roselle, L. (2013). Strategic narratives: Communication power and the new world order. New York: Routledge. google scholar
  55. O’Keefe, P., Westgate, K., & Wisner, B. (1976). Taking the “naturalness” out of “natural disasters”. Nature, 260, 566-567. google scholar
  56. Oliver-Smith, T. (1986). The martyred city: Death and rebirth in the Andes. New Mexico, USA: University of New Mexico Press. google scholar
  57. Oliver-Smith, A. (1996). Anthropological research on hazards and disasters. Annual Review of Anthropology, 25, 303-328. google scholar
  58. Oliver-Smith A. (1999). The brotherhood of pain: Theoretical and applied perspectives on post-disaster solidarity. In A. Oliver-Smith & A. Hoffman Susannah (Eds.). The angry earth: Disaster in anthropological perspective (pp. 156-172). New York: Routledge. google scholar
  59. Olson, R. S. (2000). Toward a politics of disaster: Losses, values, agendas, and blame. International Journal of Mass Emergencies & Disasters, 18(2), 265-287. google scholar
  60. Pelling, M. (2001). Natural disaster? In N. Castree, & B. Braun (Eds.), Social nature. Theory, practice andpolitics (pp. 170-188). London: Blackwell. google scholar
  61. Perry, R. W. (2007). What is a disaster? In Rodriguez, H., Quarantelli, E. L., and Dynes, R. R. (Eds.) Handbook of Disaster Research (pp. 1-15). New York: Springer. google scholar
  62. Pescaroli, G., & Alexander, D. (2015). A definition of cascading disasters and cascading effects. Planet at Risk, 3(1), 1-9. google scholar
  63. Phillips, B. D. & Fordham, M. (2010). Introduction. In Phillips, B. D., Thomas, D. S. K., Fothergill, A. and Blinn-Pike, L. (Eds.), Social Vulnerability to Disaster (pp. 1-23). Boca Raton: CRC. google scholar
  64. Prince, S. H. (1920). Catastrophe and social chance: Based upon a sociological study of the halifax disaster (Doctoral dissertation, Columbia University). google scholar
  65. Qian, L. (2021). Making Memory Work: The SARS memory and China’s war on COVID-19. Memory Studies. 14 (6): 1489-1502. google scholar
  66. Quarantelli, E. L. (1954). The nature and conditions of panic. American Journal of Sociology, 60(3), 267-275. google scholar
  67. Quarantelli, E. L. (1987). Disaster Studies: An analysis of the social and historical factors affecting the development of research in the area. International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters, 5, 285-310. google scholar
  68. Quarantelli, E. L. (1989). How individuals and groups react during disasters: Planning and managing implications for EMS delivery. Preliminary Paper. google scholar
  69. Quijia Z., Xinling, C., Guomin, M., & Rouwei, P. (1992). Prediction Research on the Economic Losses and Population Casualties of Earthquake Disasters. Unpublished Manuscript. Institute of Geophysics, State Seismological Bureau, Beijing, China. google scholar
  70. Redhouse, J. W. (1856). Redhouse’s Turkish Dictionary, in Two Parts, English and Turkish, and Turkish and English. B. Quaritch. google scholar
  71. Rodriguez, H., Donner, W., & Trainor, J. E. (Eds.) (2018). Handbook of disaster research. New York: Springer. google scholar
  72. Scanlon, J. (1996). Not on the record: Disasters, records and disaster research. International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters, 14, 265-280. google scholar
  73. Schmuck-Widmann, H. (1996). Living with the floods: Survival strategies of char-dwellers in Bangladesh. Berlin: FDCL. google scholar
  74. Schuller, M. (2016). Humanitarian aftershocks in Haiti. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press. google scholar
  75. Scolobig, A., De Marchi, B., & Borga, M. (2012). The missing link between flood risk awareness and preparedness: findings from case studies in an Alpine Region. Natural Hazards, 63, 499-520. google scholar
  76. Scott, J. C. (1999). Seeing like a state: How certain schemes to ımprove the human condition have failed. New Haven: Yale University Press. google scholar
  77. Snyder, H. (2019). Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. Journal of business research, 104, 333-339. google scholar
  78. Sözen, E. (2017). Söylem: Belirsizlik, mübadele, bilgi/güç ve refleksivite. İstanbul: Profil Kitap. google scholar
  79. Susman, P., O’Keefe, P., & Wisner, B. (2019). “Global disasters a radical interpretation.” In K. Hewitt (Ed.), Interpretations of calamity from the view point of human ecology, pp. 263-283, Routledge. google scholar
  80. Taute, N., Fa’aui, T., & Ingham, J. M. (2019). Ruaumoko: More than just a symbol. In 2019 Pacific Conference on Earthquake Engineering. Auckland, New Zealand. google scholar
  81. Tierney, K. J. (1999). Toward a Critical Sociology of Risk. Sociological Forum, 14 (2): 215 242. google scholar
  82. Tierney, K.J., Lindell, M. K., and Perry, R.W. (2001) Facing the unexpected: Disaster preparedness and response in the United States, Natural hazards and disasters. Joseph Henry Press, Washington. google scholar
  83. Tierney, K. J., Bevc, C., & Kuligowski, E. (2006). Metaphors matter: Disaster myths, media frames, and their consequences in Hurricane Katrina. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 604 (1): 57-81 google scholar
  84. Tierney, K. J. (2007). From the margins to the mainstream? Disaster research at the crossroads. Annual Review of Sociology, 33, 503-525. google scholar
  85. Tierney, K. J. (2019). Disasters: A Sociological Approach. New Jersey: John Willey & Sons. google scholar
  86. Tobin-Gurley, J., & Enarson, E. (2010). Gender. In B. D. Phillips, D. S. K. Thomas, A. Fothergill & L. Blinn-Pike (Eds.), Social Vulnerability to Disaster (pp. 139-165). Boca Raton: CRC. google scholar
  87. Torraco, R. J. (2005). Writing integrative literature reviews: Guidelines and examples. Human Resource Development Review, 4, 356-367. google scholar
  88. Wallace-Wells, D. (2019). The uninhabitable earth: Life after warming. London: Allen Lane. google scholar
  89. Webb, G. R. (2018). The Cultural Turn in Disaster Research: Understanding Resilience and Vulnerability Through the Lens of Culture. H. Rodriguez, W. Donner & J. E. Trainor (Eds.), Handbook of Disaster Research (pp.109-122). New York: Springer. google scholar
  90. Wenger, D. E., & Weller, J. M. (1973). Disaster subcultures: The cultural residues of community disasters. Preliminary Paper. google scholar
  91. Wisner, B., Blaikie, P., Cannon, T. & Davis, I. (2004). At Risk: Natural Hazards, People’s Vulnerability and Disasters. New York: Routledge. google scholar
  92. Wisner, B., Gaillard, J. C., & Kelman, I. (Eds). (2012). Framing disaster: Theories and stories seeking to understand hazards, vulnerability and risk. In Handbook of Hazards and Disaster Risk Reduction (pp. 44-62). New York: Routledge. google scholar
  93. Gould, K.A., Garcia, M.M., & Remes, J.A.C. (2016). Beyond ‘‘natural-disasters-are-not-natural’’: The work of state and natüre after the 2010 earthquake in Chile. Journal of Political Ecology. 23(1), 93-114. google scholar
  94. Kuran, C. H. A., Morsut, C., Kruke, B. I., Krüger, M., Segnestam, L., Orru, K.,. & Torpan, S. (2020). Vulnerability and vulnerable groups from an intersectionality perspective. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 50, 101826. google scholar