Journals / Mavi Atlas / 2026 / Cilt: 14 Sayı: 2

The Polemical Genesis of a Discipline: The Evolution of Methodology and the Historian’s Identity in Ancient Historiography

Bir Disiplinin Polemik Doğuşu: Antikçağ Tarih Yazımında Metodolojinin Evrimi ve Tarihçi Kimliği

Mehmet Sait Benek(MUĞLA SITKI KOÇMAN ÜNİVERSİTESİ, EDEBİYAT FAKÜLTESİ, TARİH BÖLÜMÜ)0000-0002-8761-8246
Journal
Mavi Atlas
Pages
938–953
Publication Date
2026-10-31
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

In this respect, our study is critical as it reveals that Western historiography is both an accumulation of facts and the art of methodologically liquidating its adversaries.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:Greek historiography, while keeping a record of the past on the one hand, constitutes a serious struggle for authority and legitimacy waged between successor and predecessor on the other.
📊
Key Findings & Data:This study analyzes how the methodological, ethical, and rhetorical critiques directed by historians toward their predecessors defined the boundaries of the discipline and constructed the historian’s identity as a polemical subject.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:In this respect, our study is critical as it reveals that Western historiography is both an accumulation of facts and the art of methodologically liquidating its adversaries.
🔬Design:Araştırma Makalesi
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Grek Tarih Yazımı · Tarihçi Kimliği · Polemik

Abstract

Greek historiography, while keeping a record of the past on the one hand, constitutes a serious struggle for authority and legitimacy waged between successor and predecessor on the other. This study analyzes how the methodological, ethical, and rhetorical critiques directed by historians toward their predecessors defined the boundaries of the discipline and constructed the historian’s identity as a polemical subject. The process began at the end of the fifth century BC with Thucydides, who excluded the narratives of logographers based on momentary pleasure and defined the boundaries of history as a rational and eternal possession. Ctesias, utilizing the archival authority derived from his role as a court physician, characterized Herodotus as a liar and reconfigured historical authority through access to inside information. In the Hellenistic period, Polybius condemned library-based armchair historiography in the person of Timaeus, establishing the pragmatic method, rooted in military and political practice, as a criterion of legitimacy. This plane of debate transformed into a test of moral character in the first and second centuries AD with Plutarch; malice in historical narrative was presented as the primary obstacle to objectivity. During the same period, Dionysius critiqued Thucydides’ strict rationalism through rhetorical principles, reopening the discussion on the relationship between style, the pleasure provided to the reader, and the seriousness of history. All these debates on authority and truth culminated in the second century AD with the works of Lucian, who characterized all such claims as fabrications; thus, the polemical tradition reached an ironic conclusion where the absolute authority of the historian was called into question. In this respect, our study is critical as it reveals that Western historiography is both an accumulation of facts and the art of methodologically liquidating its adversaries.

Özet

Grek tarih yazımı, bir yandan geçmişin kaydını tutarken, diğer taraftan halef ile selef arasında yürütülen ciddi bir otorite ve meşruiyet mücadelesidir. Bu çalışma, tarihçilerin öncüllerine yönelttiği metodolojik, etik ve retorik eleştirilerin, disiplinin sınırlarını nasıl belirlediğini ve tarihçi kimliğini bir polemik öznesi olarak nasıl oluşturduğunu analiz etmektedir. Süreç, MÖ V. yüzyıl sonunda Thukydides’in logografların anlık hazza dayalı anlatılarını dışlayarak tarihin sınırlarını rasyonel ve ebedi bir mülk olarak çizmesiyle başlamıştır. Ktesias, saray hekimliği üzerinden devşirdiği arşiv otoritesini kullanıp Herodotos’u bir yalancı olarak niteleyerek, tarihçi otoritesini içeriden bilgiye erişim üzerinden yeniden kurgulamıştır. Hellenistik dönemde Polybios, masabaşı araştırmaya dayalı kütüphane tarihçiliğini Timaeos nezdinde reddederek, bizzat askeri ve siyasi pratiğe dayanan pragmatik usulü bir meşruiyet ölçütü haline getirmiştir. Bu tartışma düzlemi, MS I. ve II. yüzyıllarda Plutarkhos ile birlikte ahlaki bir karakter sınavına dönüşmüş; tarihsel anlatıdaki kötü niyet, nesnelliğin önündeki en büyük engel olarak sunulmuştur. Aynı dönemde Dionysios ise Thukydides’in katı rasyonalizmini retorik ilkeler üzerinden eleştirerek, üslubun ve okuyucuya verilen hazzın tarihin ciddiyetiyle olan ilişkisini yeniden tartışmaya açmıştır. Tüm bu otorite ve hakikat tartışmaları, MS II. yüzyılda Loukianos’un bütün iddiaları birer uydurma olarak ifade ettiği aktarımlarında nihayete ermiş; polemik geleneği, tarihçinin mutlak otoritesinin sorgulandığı ironik bir sonla kapanmıştır. Bu anlamda çalışmamız, Batı tarih yazımının hem bir olgular yığını olduğunu hem de rakiplerini metodolojik olarak tasfiye etme sanatı işlevi gördüğünü ortaya koyması bakımından kritiktir.

🔖

Cite This Article

Benek, M. S. (2026). The Polemical Genesis of a Discipline: The Evolution of Methodology and the Historian’s Identity in Ancient Historiography. Mavi Atlas, Cilt: 14 Sayı: 2, 938–953. https://doi.org/10.18795/gumusmaviatlas.1941778

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (70)

  1. Abbott, G. F. (2018). Thucydides: A study in historical reality. Routledge.
  2. Allison, J. W. (1997). Word and concept in Thucydides. Scholars Press.
  3. Almagor, E. (2012). Ctesias and the importance of his writings revisited. Electrum, 19, 9-40.
  4. Andria, R. G. (2003). Novità testuali su P. Oxy. 2330 (Ctesias Cnidius, FGrHist 688 F 8b). Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik, 144, 15-18.
  5. Bakker, E. (2006). Contract and design: Thucydides’ writing. In A. Rengakos & A. Tsakmakis (Ed.), Brill’s companion to Thucydides (pp. 109-129). Brill.
  6. Bartley, A. (2003). The implications of the reception of Thucydides within Lucian’s Vera Historia. Hermes, 131(2), 222-234.
  7. Beard, M. (2025). Klasiklerle yüzleşmek: Antik tarihte yeni hesaplaşmalar (N. Şen, Çev.). Pegasus Yayınları.
  8. Bigwood, J. M. (1976). Ctesias’ account of the revolt of Inarus. Phoenix, 30(1), 1-25.
  9. Bigwood, J. M. (1978). Ctesias as historian of the Persian Wars. Phoenix, 32(1), 19-41.
  10. Bigwood, J. M. (1980). Diodorus and Ctesias. Phoenix, 34(3), 195-207.
  11. Bowen, A. J. (1992). Plutarch: The malice of Herodotus (De malignitate Herodoti). Aris & Phillips.
  12. Brown, T. S. (1978). Suggestions for a vita of Ctesias of Cnidus. Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte, 27(1), 1-19.
  13. Chrysanthou, C. S. (2020). Plutarch and the “malicious” historian. Illinois Classical Studies, 45(1), 49-79. https://doi.org/10.5406/illiclasstud.45.1.0049
  14. Cizek, A. (1975). From the historical truth to the literary convention: The life of Cyrus. L’Antiquité Classique, 44(2), 531-552.
  15. Corcella, A. (2006). The new genre and its boundaries: Poets and logographers. A. Rengakos & A. Tsakmakis (Ed.), Brill’s companion to Thucydides içinde (ss. 33-56). Brill.
  16. Demir, M. (2005). Eskiçağ tarih yazıcılığında Herodotos’un yeri ve önemi. Tarih Araştırmaları Dergisi, 24(38), 59- 78.
  17. Demir, M. (2017). Antik Yunan tarihçiliği: Herodotos ve Thukydides. İçinde A. Şimşek (Ed.), Dünya’da tarihçilik (ss. 1-28). Pegem Akademi.
  18. Demir, M. (2022). Knidoslu Ktesias’ın hayatı, eserleri ve tarih yazıcılığı üzerine değerlendirmeler. Sosyal ve Beşerî Bilimler Araştırması Dergisi, 23(51), 292-317. https://izlik.org/JA82PJ52YC
  19. Desmond, W. (2006). Lessons of fear: A reading of Thucydides. Classical Philology, 101(4), 359-379.
  20. Diodorus Siculus. (1989). Diodorus of Sicily in twelve volumes (C. H. Oldfather, Trans.). Harvard University Press.
  21. Dionysius of Halicarnassus. (1975). On Thucydides (W. K. Pritchett, Trans.). University of California Press.
  22. Doğan, A. (2023). Herodotos ve Thukydides’in eserlerinde savaş söylemi. İçinde E. Bozok vd. (Ed.), Türk harp dili ve edebiyatı sempozyumu bildiri kitabı (ss. 877-885). Millî Savunma Üniversitesi Yayınları.
  23. Evans, J. A. S. (1968). Father of history or father of lies: The reputation of Herodotus. The Classical Journal, 64(1), 11-17.
  24. Finley, J. H. (1939). The origins of Thucydides’ style. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, 50, 35-84.
  25. Finley, J. H. (1940). The unity of Thucydides’ history. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, 51(1), 255-297.
  26. Fox, M. (2001). Dionysius, Lucian, and the prejudice against rhetoric in history. The Journal of Roman Studies, 91, 76-93.
  27. Georgiadou, A., & Larmour, D. H. J. (1994). Lucian and historiography: De historia conscribenda and Verae historiae. Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt, II.34.2, 1448-1509.
  28. Gomme, A. W. (1971). A historical commentary on Thucydides: Introduction and commentary on Book I (Cilt 1). Clarendon Press.
  29. Grethlein, J. (2013). Experience and teleology in ancient historiography: “Futures past” from Herodotus to Augustine. Cambridge University Press.
  30. Hartog, F. (2015). Regimes of historicity: Presentism and experiences of time. Columbia University Press.
  31. Hecataios. (1995). Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (F. Jacoby, Ed.). Brill.
  32. Herodotos. (2011). Tarih (M. Ökmen, Çev.). Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları.
  33. Hershbell, J. P. (1993). Plutarch and Herodotus: The beetle in the rose. Rheinisches Museum für Philologie, 136(2), 143-163.
  34. Hershbell, J. P. (1997). Plutarch’s concept of history: Philosophy from examples. Ancient Society, 28, 225-243.
  35. Hesiodos. (2023). Theogonia - İşler ve günler (A. Erhat & S. Eyüboğlu, Çev.). Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları.
  36. Homeros. (2022). İlyada (A. Erhat & A. Kadir, Çev.). Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları.
  37. Hornblower, S. (1987). Thucydides. Johns Hopkins University Press.
  38. Hornblower, S. (1991). A commentary on Thucydides: Volume I: Books I-III. Clarendon Press.
  39. Hornblower, S. (2004). Thucydides and Pindar: Historical narrative and the world of epinikian poetry. Oxford University Press.
  40. Kagan, D. (2009). Thucydides: The reinvention of history. Viking.
  41. Lenfant, D. (1996). Ctésias et Hérodote, ou les réécritures de l’histoire dans la Perse achéménide. Revue des Études Grecques, 109, 348-380.
  42. Loukianos. (2020). Gerçek bir hikâye (E. Poyraz, Çev.). Pinhan Yayıncılık.
  43. Loukianos. (2021). Tarih nasıl yazılmalı (E. Poyraz, Çev.). Pinhan Yayıncılık.
  44. Luraghi, N. (2000). Author and audience in Thucydides’ Archaeology: Some reflections. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, 100, 227-239.
  45. Marincola, J. (1997). Authority and tradition in ancient historiography. Cambridge University Press.
  46. Marincola, J. (2013). Polybius, Phylarchus, and “tragic history”: A reconsideration. In B. Gibson & T. Harrison (Ed.), Polybius and his world (pp. 73-90). Oxford University Press.
  47. Moles, J. (1993). Truth and untruth in Herodotus and Thucydides. In C. Gill & T. P. Wiseman (Ed.), Lies and fiction in the ancient world (pp. 88-121). University of Exeter Press.
  48. Momigliano, A. (1990). The classical foundations of modern historiography. University of California Press.
  49. Momigliano, A. (1996). Studies in historiography. Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
  50. Morrison, J. V. (2006). Reading Thucydides. The Ohio State University Press.
  51. Pelling, C. (2002). Plutarch and history. Classical Press of Wales.
  52. Photius. (1920). Bibliotheca excerpts (J. H. Freese, Trans.). Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge
  53. Plutarch. (1914). Lives, Volume II: Themistocles and Camillus. Aristides and Cato Major. Cimon and Lucullus (B. Perrin, Trans.). Harvard University Press.
  54. Plutarch. (1965). Moralia, Volume XI: On the malice of Herodotus (L. Pearson & F. H. Sandbach, Trans.). Harvard University Press.
  55. Polybios. (2010). The histories (W. R. Paton & C. B. R. Pelling, Trans.). Harvard University Press.
  56. Pritchett, W. K. (1993). The liar school of Herodotos. Gieben.
  57. Rawlings, H. R., III. (2016). Ktema te es aiei … akouein. Classical Philology, 111(2), 107-116.
  58. Scanlon, T. F. (2015). Greek historiography. Wiley Blackwell.
  59. Snell, B. (1953). The discovery of the mind: The Greek origins of European thought (T. G. Rosenmeyer, Trans.). Harvard University Press.
  60. Stronk, J. P. (2004-2005). Ctesias of Cnidus: From physician to author. Talanta, 36-37, 101-122.
  61. Stronk, J. P. (2007). Ctesias of Cnidus, a reappraisal. Mnemosyne, 60, 25-58.
  62. Stronk, J. P. (2010). Ctesias’ Persian history: Part I: Introduction, text and translation. Wellem Verlag.
  63. Tamiolaki, M. (2015). Satire and historiography: The reception of classical models and the construction of the author’s persona in Lucian’s De historia conscribenda. Mnemosyne, 68(6), 917-936.
  64. Thomas, R. (1992). Oral tradition and written record in classical Athens. Cambridge University Press.
  65. Thucydides. (1972). History of the Peloponnesian War (R. Warner, Trans.). Penguin Classics.
  66. Walbank, F. W. (2002). Polybius, Rome and the Hellenistic world: Essays and reflections. Cambridge University Press.
  67. Whitmarsh, T. (2001). Greek literature and the Roman Empire: The politics of imitation. Cambridge University Press.
  68. Wiseman, T. P. (1979). Clio’s cosmetics: Three studies in Greco-Roman historiography. Leicester University Press.
  69. Woodman, A. J. (1988). Rhetoric in classical historiography: Four studies. Croom Helm.
  70. Yardımcı, A. B. (2025). Thukydides’in tarih anlayışı. İçinde M. A. Sarı (Ed.), Antik Çağ’dan günümüze tarih felsefesi (ss. 27-42). Akademisyen Kitabevi.