AI Summary & Key Takeaways
AI InsightIn conclusion, the abstract intellect is removed from being a necessary link in the chain of emanation, and the universe is grounded as the direct and volitional act of God.
📌 3 Key Takeaways
Abstract
Naṣīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī’s interpretation of the abstract intellect (al-ʿaql al-mujarrad) constitutes a remarkable example of the interaction between Peripatetic Islamic philosophy and the kalām tradition. In the literature, al-Ṭūsī’s conception of the abstract intellect has often been treated either as a mere continuation of the Peripatetic emanationist system or within the framework of a theological refutation; consequently, the specific epistemological and ontological justifications through which he reconstructed this concept have not been sufficiently elucidated. This article aims to examine al-Ṭūsī's approach in the context of his establishing a strong dialogue with the philosophical tradition to reinterpret certain fundamental concepts based on kalām principles, and his specific departure from the Peripatetics regarding the abstract intellect, thereby filling this conceptual gap in the literature. The study employs a method of textual and comparative analysis, focusing on the author’s fundamental works such as Ithbāt al-ʿAql al-Mujarrad and Tajrīd al-Iʿtiqād. The primary findings of the article are as follows: al-Ṭūsī grounds the existence of the abstract intellect by identifying it as the necessary locus (maḥall) of nafs al-amr, which serves as the epistemological foundation of truth. He demonstrates that certain (yaqīnī) judgments can only be true through correspondence with an external, immutable, and non-corporeal reality. Arguing that this reality can be neither a body, nor an accident, nor an Idea, al-Ṭūsī concludes that it can only be understood as forms residing in an abstract intellect. While this acceptance regarding the existence of the abstract intellect brings al-Ṭūsī onto common ground with Islamic philosophers, it distinguishes him from this tradition concerning the origin of the abstract intellect and its relationship with God. al-Ṭūsī rejects the chain of abstract intellects based on the theory of emanation (ṣudūr) and the notion of these intellects as necessary ontological intermediaries between God and the world, on the grounds that they are incompatible with God’s absolute will and freedom in creation. Within this framework, he critiques the Peripatetic principle that “from one, only one proceeds” and the conception of God as a necessary agent by essence (mūjib bi-dh-dhāt). In conclusion, the abstract intellect is removed from being a necessary link in the chain of emanation, and the universe is grounded as the direct and volitional act of God. Accordingly, the study demonstrates that al-Ṭūsī proposes an original model of an abstract intellect that is singular in essence, in place of the Peripatetic scheme of hierarchical intellects.
Özet
Nasîrüddin Tûsî’nin mücerret akıl yorumu, Meşşâî felsefe ile kelam disiplini arasındaki etkileşimin dikkate değer örneklerinden biridir. Literatürde onun bu yaklaşımı genellikle ya Meşşâî sudûrcu sistemin bir uzantısı olarak değerlendirilmiş ya da onun bu kavramı bütünüyle reddettiği öne sürülmüş; kavramı hangi epistemolojik ve ontolojik gerekçelerle yeniden temellendirdiği yeterince aydınlatılmamıştır. Bu makale, Tûsî’nin söz konusu felsefî kavramı kelamî ilkeler ekseninde nasıl yorumladığını incelemektedir. Çalışmada İsbâtu’l-ʿakli’l-mücerred ve Tecrîdü’l-iʿtikâd adlı eserler merkeze alınarak metin ve karşılaştırmalı analiz yöntemi benimsenmiştir. Araştırma sonucunda Tûsî'nin, mücerret aklın varlığını doğruluğun zemini olan nefsü’l-emrin zorunlu mahalli olarak ispatladığı görülmüştür. Mücerret aklın kabulü Tûsî’yi İslam filozoflarıyla ortak zeminde buluştursa da onun ontolojik konumu bağlamında onlardan ayrılmıştır. Zira Tûsî, Allah’ın mutlak iradesiyle çeliştiği gerekçesiyle sudûr teorisini ve Tanrı ile âlem arasındaki zorunlu aracı varlıklar fikrini reddeder. Sonuç olarak Tûsî, evreni bu zorunlu zincirin bir uzantısı değil, Allah’ın doğrudan ve iradî fiili olarak temellendirmiş; Meşşâîlerin hiyerarşik akıllar şeması yerine tekli bir mücerret akıl anlayışı ortaya koymuştur.