Journals / sinecine: Sinema Araştırmaları Dergisi / 2018 / Cilt: 9 Sayı: 1

The Historical Film As Real History

Gerçek Tarih Olarak Tarihsel Film

Robert A. Rosenstone(The California Institute of Technology)
Pages
159–181
Publication Date
2018-05-11
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

In each of these three categories, history is reshaped by cinematographic methods, techniques, and aesthetic de cisions, and historical reality undergoes a cinematic reconstruction.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:Cinema has been concerned with history from its earlier days.
📊
Key Findings & Data:The inclusion of historical representations in cinema has been of interest to academic historians over time and some have collaborated with filmmakers in various ways, such as consulting for authenticity, being expert guests in documentaries, writing academic film reviews, and conducting related research.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:In each of these three categories, history is reshaped by cinematographic methods, techniques, and aesthetic de cisions, and historical reality undergoes a cinematic reconstruction.
🔬Design:Review & Systematic Survey
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Sinema · tarih · tarihsel film

Abstract

Cinema has been concerned with history from its earlier days. Historical events and people have become popular subjects for film directors. The inclusion of historical representations in cinema has been of interest to academic historians over time and some have collaborated with filmmakers in various ways, such as consulting for authenticity, being expert guests in documentaries, writing academic film reviews, and conducting related research. This dialogue between historians and cinematographers generated the questions “What is a historical film?”, “What is the relationship or difference between written history and cin ematic history?”, and “If written history is not a mirror but a construction, then what is the relation between reality and filmed history?” Just as it is possible to divide written history into a number of categories, filmed history can be seen as “history as drama,” “history as anti-drama,” “unheroic history,” “history as an exhibition,” “history as an article,” “oral history,” “post-modern history,” and so on. However, in this article, historical representations in cinema are reduced to three broad categories, “history as drama,” “history as a document,” and “history as an experiment.” “History as drama” is created in the film by dramatization of real or fictional characters in historical settings. “History as a document” is the representation of various films, photographs, works, tables, graphics, newspa - per and magazine clippings on screen in the presence of narrators, witnesses, or experts. “History as an experiment” is a combination of both, embodying both dramatic and documentary characteristics. In each of these three categories, history is reshaped by cinematographic methods, techniques, and aesthetic de cisions, and historical reality undergoes a cinematic reconstruction.

Özet

Sinema daha ilk günlerinden itibaren birçok alanla olduğu gibi tarihle de ilgilen meye başlamış, tarihsel olay ve kişiler yönetmenlerin en popüler konularından biri olmuştur. Sinemada tarihsel temsillere yer verilmesi zaman içinde akade mik tarihçilerin de ilgisini çekmiş ve bu durum tarihçileri, danışmanlık, belge sellerde uzman konuk olma ya da akademik film incelemeleri yapma gibi çeşitli biçimlerde sinemacılarla iş birliği yapmaya ya da bu alanda eserler vermeye yö neltmiştir. Tarihçiler ve sinemacılar arasında kurulan bu iletişim “Tarihsel film nedir?”, “Yazılı tarih ile sinemasal tarih arasında nasıl bir ilişki ya da ne gibi bir fark vardır?” ve “Yazılı tarihi bir ayna değil de bir inşa kabul edersek, filmdeki tarihin gerçeklikle ilişkisi nedir?” sorularını doğurmuştur. Nasıl ki yazılı tarihi birtakım kategorilere ayırmak mümkün ise “filmdeki tarihi” de “drama olarak tarih”, “antidrama olarak tarih”, “kahramansız tarih”, “gösteri olarak tarih”, “ma - kale olarak tarih”, “kişisel tarih”, “sözlü tarih”, “postmodern tarih” gibi birtakım kategorilere ayırmak mümkündür. Ancak bu makalede sinemadaki tarih temsil leri, “drama olarak tarih”, “belge olarak tarih” ve “deney olarak tarih” olmak üzere üç geniş kategoriye indirgenmektedir. “Drama olarak tarih”, filmde gerçek ya da kurgusal karakterlerin tarihi ortamda dramatize edilmesiyle oluşturulur. “Bel ge olarak tarih” ise çeşitli filmler, fotoğraflar, eserler, tablolar, grafikler, gazete ve dergi kupürlerinin anlatıcı, tanıklar veya uzmanlar eşliğinde beyazperdede sunulmasıdır. “Deney olarak tarih” ise hem dramatik hem de belgesel özellikleri gösteren, ikisinin bir kombinasyonudur. Tabii bu üç kategoride de tarih, sinema nın anlatım yöntemleri, teknikleri ve estetik olanaklarıyla yeniden şekillenmek te ve tarihsel gerçeklik bu defa da sinemasal bir yeniden inşaya uğramaktadır.

🔖

Cite This Article

Rosenstone, R. A. (2018). The Historical Film As Real History. sinecine: Sinema Araştırmaları Dergisi, Cilt: 9 Sayı: 1, 159–181. https://ajindex.com/articles/1338433

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (5)

  1. Davis, N. Z. (1983), The Return of Martin Guerre, Cambridge, Mass., s. viii.
  2. Davis, N. Z. (1987). Any Resemblance to Persons Living or Dead’: Film and the Challenge of Authenticity, Yale Review, No. 76, September, pp. 457-82.
  3. O’ Connor, J. E., Jackson, M. A. (1979). American History/American Film: Interpreting the Hollywood Image (eds.), New York. The ‘Glory’ Story. (1990). New Republic, No; 202, January 8, pp. 22- 27.
  4. Walkowitz, D. J. (1985). Visual History: The Craft of the Historian- Filmmaker, Public Historian, No.7, Winter, s. 57.
  5. White, H. (1988). Historiography and Historiophoty. The American Historical Review, Volume 93, Issue 5, 1 December, pp. 1193.