The Effect of the Open and Closed System Suctions on Pain Severity and Physiological Indicators in Mechanically Ventilated Patients with Traumatic Brain Injury: A Randomised Controlled Trial

Özet

Objective: Tracheal suctioning can cause pain and physiological indicator variations in patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI). The aim ofthe present study was to compare pain severity and physiological indicator variations during the closed tracheal suction system (CTSS) and opentracheal suction system (OTSS) in patients with TBI.Methods: This study was a clinical trial. Samples included all ventilated patients with TBI. The patients were randomly divided into the OTSSand CTSS groups. In both groups, the Critical Care Pain Observation Tool (CPOT) and physiological indicators were recorded by three nursesprior to suctioning, the end of suctioning and 5 min after suction completion. Data were analysed using the independent t-test and repeatedmeasurement tests.Results: A total of 112 patients participated in the present study. Before the interventions, the mean value of the Glasgow Coma Scale was6.45±1.13, blood pressure 128.33±20.54, saturated oxygen in arterial blood (SpO2) 96.74±2.76, respiratory rate (RR) 15.06±3.98, end-tidalCO2 (EtCO2) 36.2±21.98, heart rate 82.18±42.33 and CPOT-based pain 0.43±0.94 in the patients. Independent t-test was used to compareCTSS and OTSS, suggesting significant differences with respect to the mean values of SpO2, RR and EtCO2 immediately after suctioning. Thistest showed significant differences between the two groups with respect to pain intensity at all three points of measurement. The two groups werealso found to be significantly different with respect to RR measured 5 min after suctioning (p<0.05).Conclusion: Compared to OTSS, CTSS can cause higher reductions in pain levels during and after suctioning in patients with head traumasand can also cause higher improvements in physiological indicators, such as RR, O2 saturation and EtCO2.