A Different Perspective on that Critic Has Been Levelled at Abu Huraıra in Iksâr al-Ahadith (narrating a lot of hadith)

EBÛ HUREYRE’YE YÖNELİK İKSÂRU’L-HADÎS ELEŞTİRİSİNE FARKLI BİR BAKIŞ

Abstract

A Different Perspective on that Critic Has Been Levelled at Abu Huraıra in Iksâr al-Ahadith (narrating a lot of hadith)Abu Hurayrah is one of the most discussed figures on the hadith history. These discussions have persisted from the period of his life to the present day at different frequencies.In these discussions, a number of criticisms against Abu Hurayrah has been seen. In this context, one of the criticisms leveled at him is that he had narrated a lot of hadith.In this study, the terms of the relevant narrations are discussed in terms of signify and authenticity. It has been studied to determine the meaning of the criticisms accordance with narrated and other relevant information.

Özet

ÖZHadis tarihinde en çok tartışılan şahsiyetlerden birisi Ebû Hureyre’dir. Onunmerkezinde olduğu tartışmalar hayatta olduğu dönemden günümüze kadar değişikfrekanslarda devam edegelmiştir.İlgili tartışmalarda Ebû Hureyre’ye yönelik bir takım eleştirilerin olduğu görülmektedir.Bu meyanda kendisine yöneltilen eleştirilerden birisi de çok hadisrivayet ettiği şeklindedir.Bu çalışmada konuyla ilgili rivayetler sübut ve delâlet açısından ele alınmış,konuyla ilgili diğer rivayet ve bilgiler çerçevesinde yapılan tenkitin manası tespitedilmeye çalışılmıştır.Anahtar Kelimeler: Ebû Hureyre, tenkit, iksâru’l-hadîs, sahabe. ABSTRACTA Different Perspective on that Critic Has Been Levelled at Abu Huraıra in Iksâr al-Ahadith (narrating a lot of hadith)Abu Hurayrah is one of the most discussed figures on the hadith history. Thesediscussions have persisted from the period of his life to the present day at differentfrequencies.In these discussions, a number of criticisms against Abu Hurayrah has beenseen. In this context, one of the criticisms leveled at him is that he had narrated alot of hadith.In this study, the terms of the relevant narrations are discussed in terms of signifyand authenticity. It has been studied to determine the meaning of the criticismsaccordance with narrated and other relevant information.Keywords: Abu Hurayrah, Criticism, Ikthâr al-Ahadith (narrating a lot of hadith), the Companions.