Journals / Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi Dergisi / 2018 / Sayı: 11

(National Identity from Perspective of European Law)

AVRUPA HUKUKU PERSPEKTİFİNDEN ULUSAL KİMLİK

Pages
49–66
Publication Date
2018-06-21
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

However, at the level of the Union, there is also a core area in which constitutional identity, including nationally shaped principles such as freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law, respect for human rights, and solidarity, is absolutely protected.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:The European Union respects national identities of the member states including constitutional identity.
📊
Key Findings & Data:In this respect, the structural preferences of constitutional law are protected.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:However, at the level of the Union, there is also a core area in which constitutional identity, including nationally shaped principles such as freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law, respect for human rights, and solidarity, is absolutely protected.
🔬Design:Research Article
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Kültürel çeşitlilik · anayasal strüktür (yapı) · AB direktifi

Abstract

The European Union respects national identities of the member states including constitutional identity. In this respect, the structural preferences of constitutional law are protected. Whether or not the constitutional regulation is a subject of national identity is determined according to the Union Law. The European Court of Justice takes decisions of national high courts into consideration while interpreting concepts in this context. The concept of identity in the European law does not always coincide with the concept of identity in national law. For example, while the Federal German Constitutional Court considers an absolute national identity protection, the European Court of Justice acts on a proportional basis. However, at the level of the Union, there is also a core area in which constitutional identity, including nationally shaped principles such as freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law, respect for human rights, and solidarity, is absolutely protected.

Özet

AB üye devletlerin ulusal kimliğine saygı gösterir. Bu kimliğe anayasal kimlik dahildir. Bu prensibe istinaden anayasa hukukunun strüktürel (yapısal) tercihleri korunur. Anayasa düzenlemesinin ulusal kimliğe ait bir konu olup olmadığı Birlik hukukunun ölçülerine göre tayin edilir. ABAD kavramların yorumunda bu çerçevede ulusal yüksek mahkemelerin kararlarını dikkate alır. Birlik hukukunda yer alan kimlik kavramı ulusal hukukta karşımıza çıkan kimlik kavramıyla her zaman örtüşmemektedir. Örneğin Federal Alman Anayasa Mahkemesi mutlak bir ulusal kimlik koruması kabul ederken, ABAD nisbi bir korumadan hareket etmektedir. Bununla beraber Birlik seviyesinde de özgürlük, demokrasi, eşitlik, hukuk devleti, insan haklarına saygı, dayanışma gibi ulusal karakterli prensipleri kapsayan anayasal kimliğin mutlak olarak korunduğu çekirdek bir alan söz konusudur.

🔖

Cite This Article

ARSAVA, P. D. A. F. (2018). (National Identity from Perspective of European Law). Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi Dergisi, Sayı: 11, 49–66. https://ajindex.com/articles/975924

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (1)

  1. Albert Bleckmann Die Wahrung der “nationalen Identität” im Unionsvertrag, JZ 1997 Armin Hatje bknz.: Jürgen Schwarze/Ulrich Becker/Armin Hatje/Johann Schoo (Hrsg.), EU Kommentar, 3.Aufl. 2012, Art.4 EUV, Rn.49 Arwin v. Bogdandy/ Die Achtung der nationalen Identität unter dem reformierten Stephan Schill Unionsvetrag. Zur Unionsrechtlice Rolle nationalen Verfassungsrechts und zur Überwindung des absoluten Vorrangs, ZaöRV 70 (2010) Andreas Haratsch Das Integrationsstaatsprinzip des Grundgesetzes, bknz.: Festschrift für Eckart Klein, 2013 Andreas Haratsch Wechselwirkungen zwischen deutscher und europäischer Identität – Ausdruck von Eigenständigkeit und Gemeinsamkeit, bknz.: Hans Jörg Bücking/Eckhard Jesse, Deutsche Identität in Europa, 2008 Armin v.Bogdandy/ bknz.: Eberhard Grabitz/Meinhard Hilf/Martin Nettesheim (Hrsg.), Stephan Schill Das Recht der EU, Art.51. 2015, Art.4 EUV, Rn.35 Albert Bleckmann/ bknz.: Albert Bleckmann, Europarecht, 6.Aufl. 1997, Rn.30 Stefan Ulrich.Pieper Christopf Vedder “bknz.: Vedder/Wolff Heintschel v.Heinegg (Hrsg.), Europäisches Unionsrecht, 2012, Art. 4 EUV, Rn.11 Eckart Klein, Europäischer Grundrechtsschutz und nationale Identität, bknz.: Matthias Niedobitek/Karl-Peter Sommermann (Hrsg.), Eckart Klein Staatssymbole bknz.: Josef Isensee/Paul Kirchof (Hrsg.), HStR, Bd.II, 3.Aufl. 2004, §19, Rn.1 Franz C.Mayer/ bknz.: Armin Hatje/Peter Christian Müller-Graff (Hrsg.), Europäisches Mattias Wendel Organisations- und Verfassungsrecht (EnzEuR Bd.1, §4, Rn.256) Hans Heinrich Rupp Bemerkungen zum europäischen Schutz der “nationalen Identität” der EU – Mitgliedstaaten, bknz.: Festschrift für W.Rudolf, 2001 Hermann-Josef Blanke bknz.: Hermann-Josef Blanke/Stello Mangiameli (Hrsg.), The Treaty on European Union (TEU), A Commentary, 2013, Art.4 EUV Karl Rudolf Korte Das Dilemma des Nationalstaates in Westeuropa: Zur Identitätsproblematik der europäischen Integration, bknz.: Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte, B 14/1993 Konrad Hesse Grundzüge des Verfassungsrechts der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, 20.Aufl. 1995, Rn.113 Maja Walter Integrationsgrenze Verfassungsidentität – Konzept und Kontrolle aus europäischer, deutscher und französischer Perspektive, ZaöRV 72 (2012) Oliver Dörr Der europäisierte Rechtsschutzauftrag deutscher Gerichte, 2003 Roland Bieber §29, Rn.1, bknz.: Roland Bieber/ Astrid Epiney/ Marcel Haag, Die Europäische Union, 11.Aufl. 2015 Stephan Hobe Der offene Verfassungsstaat zwischen Souveränität und Interdependenz, 1998 Ulrich R.Ha