Journals / PHILIA / 2019 / Cilt: 5

«Salut ! humble monnaie, enfant d’Hyllarima». A Strange Poem to the Glory of a Modern Fake?

«Selam! Mütevazi Sikke, Hyllarima’nın Evladı». Sahte Bir Sikke’nin Şanı Hakkında Garip Bir Şiir?

Journal
PHILIA
Pages
41–51
Publication Date
2019-12-24
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

Obviously, one of the two coins, at least that of Vienna, or both, is a modern fake, as counterfeiters produced large quantities in the nineteenth century.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:The ancient coinage of Hyllarima in Caria is the cause of a poem composed in 1891 by the Russian numismatist and antiquarian Alexandre-Pierre Boutkowski-Glinka.
📊
Key Findings & Data:This very strange work, of which we publish the full commented text, is an opportunity to present the chaotic life and career of its author.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:Obviously, one of the two coins, at least that of Vienna, or both, is a modern fake, as counterfeiters produced large quantities in the nineteenth century.
🔬Design:Research Article
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Karia · Sikke · Hyllarima

Abstract

The ancient coinage of Hyllarima in Caria is the cause of a poem composed in 1891 by the Russian numismatist and antiquarian Alexandre-Pierre Boutkowski-Glinka. This very strange work, of which we publish the full commented text, is an opportunity to present the chaotic life and career of its author. Passionate about coins, he wrote several books and articles on Greek numismatics that were sometimes criticized, and even a source of controversy. Among these are a case of resounding plagiarism, but also a Roman provincial coin of Hyllarima, pretext for the poem «Salut ! humble monnaie, enfant d’Hyllarima». Acquired by Alexandre-Pierre Boutkowski-Glinka in obscure conditions, the coin, today in the Département des Monnaies, Médailles et Antiques of the Bibliothèque Nationale de France, is a bronze of the time of Antoninus Pius with the image of Boule (?) on the obverse and that of a charioteer (perhaps the emperor) on a chariot pulled by four horses on the reverse. An exact copy of it is kept at the Münzkabinett of the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna. Obviously, one of the two coins, at least that of Vienna, or both, is a modern fake, as counterfeiters produced large quantities in the nineteenth century.

Özet

Karia’da Hyllarima’nın antik sikkeleri, 1891 yılında Rus nümismat ve antikacı Alexandre-Pierre Boutkowski-Glinka tarafından bestelenen bir şiire vesile olmuştur. Yorumlanan metnin tamamını yayınladığımız bu çok garip eser, yazarının kaotik yaşamını ve kariyerini sunma fırsatıdır. Kendisi sikke konusunda tutkuluydu, Yunan nümismatiği üzerine bazen eleştirilen ve hatta bir tartışma kaynağı olan birkaç kitap ve makale yazmıştır. Bunlar arasında yankılanan bir intihal vakası vardır, aynı zamanda bir şiire vesile olan Hyllarima’nın bir Roma eyalet sikkesini yayımlanmıştır: «Selam! mütevazi sikke, Hyllarima’nın evladı». Alexandre-Pierre Boutkowski-Glinka tarafından belirsiz koşullar altında elde edilen ve Antoninus Pius döneminden ön yüzünde Boule (?), arka yüzünde ise dört atlı bir arabayı kullanan arabacı (belki de imparator) tasvirli söz konusu bronz sikke, bugün «Bibliothèque Nationale de France, Département des Monnaies, Médailles»’da korunmaktadır. Bunun tam bir kopyası Viyana’daki «Kunsthistorisches Museum, Münzkabinett»’te saklanır. Söz konusu sikkelerden Viyana’daki örnek kesin, diğeri de on dokuzuncu yüzyılda kalpazanların büyük miktarlarda ürettikleri sahte sikkeler gibi olasılıkla modern bir sahtedir.

🔖

Cite This Article

DELRIEUX, F. (2019). «Salut ! humble monnaie, enfant d’Hyllarima». A Strange Poem to the Glory of a Modern Fake?. PHILIA, Cilt: 5, 41–51. https://ajindex.com/articles/841805

References (6)

  1. AJN 1897 Obituary: Alexandre Boutkowski, AJN 31, fasc. 3, 1897, 88–89. Arefiev 2017
  2. V. Arefiev, Alexander Boutkowski-Glinka. His Life and Works, Philadelphie 2017 (en russe). Babelon 1892 E. Babelon, Monnaies grecques récemment acquises par le Cabinet des Médailles, RN, 3e série, t. 10, 1892, 105–124. Babelon 1898 E. Babelon, Inventaire sommaire de la collection Waddington acquise par l’État en 1897 pour le Département des médailles et antiques de la Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris 1898. Babelon 1901
  3. E. Babelon, Traité des monnaies grecques et romaines, I: théorie et doctrine, 1, Paris 1901. Becker 1868a P. Becker, Ein Plagiat, Berliner Blätter für Münz-, Siegel- und Wappenkunde 4, 1868, 304–306. Becker 1868b P. Becker, Monnaies de Tius de Bithynie, RN 2e série, t. 13, 1868, 307–308. Boutkowski 1864 A. Boutkowski, Recherches historiques sur la ville de Tium (en Bithynie) et description d’une médaille inédite appartenant à cette ville, Paris 1864. Boutkowski 1867 A. Boutkowski, Supplément aux recherches sur la ville de Tium (en Bithynie) et monographie de plusieurs médailles inédites de cette ville, dont une atteste une épithète inconnue de Jupiter: Zeus Eurésius (ZЄYC ЄYPHCIOC), suivies d’un catalogue général (avec prix) de toutes les médailles de Tium déjà connues et publiées par différents auteurs, Heidelberg 1867. Boutkowski 1883 A. Boutkowski, Monnaies grecques inédites (autonomes et impériales), RN 3e série, t. 1, 1883, 375–383. Boutkowski 1884 A. Boutkowski, Monnaies grecques inédites, RN 3e série, t. 2, 1884, 401–406. Boutkowski 1892 A. Boutkowski, Recueil spécial de grandes curiosités inédites et peu connues dans le champ de l’archéologie, de la numismatique et de l’épigraphie, Paris 1892. Boutkowski 1893 A. Boutkowski, A Few Rare Greek Coins published Recently, NCir 5, 1893, 195–197. Brousseau 2013
  4. L. Brousseau, Un faux octobole d’Érétrie des collections Stack, BCD et Jameson, BSFN 68, n° 3, 2013, 44–50. Brousseau 2018
  5. L. Brousseau, De Paris à Boston, un faux didrachme de Kos, BSFN 73, n° 7, 2018, 354–355. Debord – Varinlioğlu 2018 P. Debord – E. Varinlioğlu, Hyllarima de Carie. État de la question, Bordeaux 2018. Deloche 1896 E. Deloche, Alexandre Boutkowski, RN 3e série, t. 14, 1896, 472–473. Delrieux 2008 F. Delrieux Les monnaies des cités grecques de la basse vallée de l’Harpasos en Carie (IIe s. a.C. – IIIe s. p.C.), Numismatica Anatolica, 3, Bordeaux 2008. Delrieux 2014a
  6. F. Delrieux, La redécouverte de la Carie antique, d’Ibn Baṭṭtûṭa à Louis