Journals / Selçuk Üniversitesi Türkiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi / 2019 / Cilt: 0 - Sayı: 47

SOME LIMITATIONS ON THE CONTROLLABILITY OF THE REFERENT IN TURKISH DEMONSTRATIVES

TÜRKÇE İŞARET SÖZCÜKLERİNDE GÖNDERGENİN KONTROL EDİLEBİLİRLİĞİ ÜZERİNDEKİ BAZI KISITLAMALAR

Pages
73–84
Publication Date
2022-11-05
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

In thisstudy, it is shown that Turkish has a phenomenon which cannot be purely explained in terms of thisconcept, and it is argued that (i) there are some limiting conditions determining the distribution ofthe non-anaphoric demonstratives other than this parameter in Turkish demonstrative use, (ii) theinterchangeability between the antecedent noun and the co-referential noun is one of the crucialfactors that are operative in the selection of the appropriate usages of the non-anaphoric bu and o, (iii)on the situation where the intended referent is within the controllable domain of the speaker, ‘bu’ isused to refer to it if the co-referential noun semantically contains the antecedent noun, and ‘o’ is usedto refer to it if the antecedent noun contains the co-referential noun, (iv) on the situation where thereferent is not within the controllable domain of the speaker, ‘o’ refers to it regardless of whether theco-referential noun semantically contains the antecedent noun or not, (v) time is a secondary factorconditioning whether the intended referent is within the controllable domain of the speaker or not.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:More recent linguistic works on Turkish demonstratives have turned their attention to theconcept of controllability which is one of the pragmatico-semantic parameters and which conditionsthe occurrence of the text-dependent (non-anaphoric) usages of bu and o in the verbal text.
📊
Key Findings & Data:More recent linguistic works on Turkish demonstratives have turned their attention to theconcept of controllability which is one of the pragmatico-semantic parameters and which conditionsthe occurrence of the text-dependent (non-anaphoric) usages of bu and o in the verbal text.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:In thisstudy, it is shown that Turkish has a phenomenon which cannot be purely explained in terms of thisconcept, and it is argued that (i) there are some limiting conditions determining the distribution ofthe non-anaphoric demonstratives other than this parameter in Turkish demonstrative use, (ii) theinterchangeability between the antecedent noun and the co-referential noun is one of the crucialfactors that are operative in the selection of the appropriate usages of the non-anaphoric bu and o, (iii)on the situation where the intended referent is within the controllable domain of the speaker, ‘bu’ isused to refer to it if the co-referential noun semantically contains the antecedent noun, and ‘o’ is usedto refer to it if the antecedent noun contains the co-referential noun, (iv) on the situation where thereferent is not within the controllable domain of the speaker, ‘o’ refers to it regardless of whether theco-referential noun semantically contains the antecedent noun or not, (v) time is a secondary factorconditioning whether the intended referent is within the controllable domain of the speaker or not.
🔬Design:Research Article
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Domain Parameters

Abstract

More recent linguistic works on Turkish demonstratives have turned their attention to theconcept of controllability which is one of the pragmatico-semantic parameters and which conditionsthe occurrence of the text-dependent (non-anaphoric) usages of bu and o in the verbal text. In thisstudy, it is shown that Turkish has a phenomenon which cannot be purely explained in terms of thisconcept, and it is argued that (i) there are some limiting conditions determining the distribution ofthe non-anaphoric demonstratives other than this parameter in Turkish demonstrative use, (ii) theinterchangeability between the antecedent noun and the co-referential noun is one of the crucialfactors that are operative in the selection of the appropriate usages of the non-anaphoric bu and o, (iii)on the situation where the intended referent is within the controllable domain of the speaker, ‘bu’ isused to refer to it if the co-referential noun semantically contains the antecedent noun, and ‘o’ is usedto refer to it if the antecedent noun contains the co-referential noun, (iv) on the situation where thereferent is not within the controllable domain of the speaker, ‘o’ refers to it regardless of whether theco-referential noun semantically contains the antecedent noun or not, (v) time is a secondary factorconditioning whether the intended referent is within the controllable domain of the speaker or not.

Özet

Türkiye Türkçesindeki işaret sözcükleri üzerine yapılan yakın zamandaki çalışmalar, edimsel ve anlamsal değiştirgenlerden biri olan, bu ve o sözcüklerinin metne bağlı (artgönderimsel olmayan) kullanımlarını belli bir şarta bağlayan kontrol edilebilirlik kavramına odaklanmıştır. Bu çalışmada, Türkçenin, bu kavram ile tamamen açıklanamayan bir olguya sahip olduğu gösterilerek şu konulara vurgu yapılacaktır: (i) Türkçe işaret sözcüklerinin kullanımında, kontrol edilebilirlik kavramı dışında, artgönderimsel olmayan işaret sözcüklerinin dağılımını belirleyen bazı sınırlandırıcı koşullar bulunmaktadır, (ii) öncül ad ve eşgönderimsel adın birbiriyle değiştirilebilme özelliği, bu ve o’nun artgönderimsel olmayan kullanımlarını belirlemedeki en önemli etmenlerden biridir, (iii) göndergenin konuşucunun kontrol edilebilir alanı içinde olduğu durumlarda; eğer eşgönderimsel ad anlamsal olarak öncül adı kapsıyorsa ‘bu’, eğer öncül ad anlamsal olarak eşgönderimsel adı kapsıyorsa ‘o’ işaret sözcüğü sözkonusu göndergeyi işaretler, (iv) göndergenin konuşucunun kontrol edilebilir alanı dışında olduğu durumlarda, eşgönderimsel adın öncül adı anlamsal olarak kapsayıp kapsamadığına bakılmaksızın ‘o’ işaret sözcüğü göndergeyi işaretlemek için kullanılır, (v) zaman, işaretlenmek istenen göndergenin konuşucunun kontrol edilebilir alanı içinde olup olmadığını belirleyen ikincil bir etmendir.

🔖

Cite This Article

BALPINAR, M. (2022). SOME LIMITATIONS ON THE CONTROLLABILITY OF THE REFERENT IN TURKISH DEMONSTRATIVES. Selçuk Üniversitesi Türkiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi, Cilt: 0 - Sayı: 47, 73–84. https://ajindex.com/articles/654032

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (18)

  1. BALPINAR, Metin (2011), ‚Torukogo shijishi no bunmyaku shiji yōhō ni tsuite: Bunshōōkei toshite no bu, o no yōhō‛ *On the the text dependent use of Turkish demonstratives: the usage of bu and o as sentence anaphor]. Kyōto Daigaku Gengogaku Kenkyū, 30: 71-105.
  2. BALPINAR, Metin (2012), ‚Torukogo shijishi ni okeru hibunmyaku shiji yōhō to bunmyaku shiji yōhō ni tsuite: bunmyaku shiji yōhō wo chūshin ni‛ *On non-text and text dependent uses of Turkish demonstratives: focusing on text dependent use]. Ajia & Afurika Gengo Bunka Kenkyū, 83: 89-116.
  3. BALPINAR, Metin (2014), ‚Torukogo shijishi ni okeru hibunmyaku shiji yōhō no saikentō‛ *Re-examination of the non-text dependent use of Turkish demonstratives]. Tōkyō Daigaku Gengogaku Ronshū, 35: 21-39.
  4. BALPINAR, Metin (2019), Demonstratives and Grammaticalization: A Perspective from Modern Turkish, London and New York: Routledge. BANGUOĞLU, Tahsin (2004), Türkçe’nin Grameri, Ankara:
  5. Türk Dil Kurumu. BASTUJI, Jacqueline (1976), Les Relations Spatiales en Turc Contemporain; Étude Sémantique. Paris: Éditions Klincksieck. BAYDUR, Memet (2009),
  6. Tiyatro Oyunları, İstanbul:
  7. İletişim Yayınları.
  8. ERGİN, Muharrem (1958),
  9. Türk Dil Bilgisi, İstanbul: İstanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Yayınları.
  10. GENCAN, Tahir Nejat (2001),
  11. Dilbilgisi, Ankara:
  12. Türk Dil Kurumu. GÖKSEL, Aslı - KERSLAKE, Celia (2005), Turkish: A Comprehensive Grammar, London and New York: Routledge. HAYASI, Tōru (1985), ‚Torukogo no shijishi‛ *Turkish demonstratives]. Ajia & Afurika Gengo Bunka Kenkyūjo Tsūshin, 53: 55-57.
  13. HAYASI, Tōru (1989), ‚Torukogo no susume 3: ‘kore-sore-are’ are kore‛ *An invitation to Turkish 3: ‘kore, sore, are’ are kore+. Gengo, 18.1: 96-101.
  14. HAYASI, Tōru (2004), ‚Türkçe ve Japonca İşaret Sözcükleri Üzerine Bir Deneme‛. Dilbilim Araştırmaları, 2004: 51-62.
  15. HAYASI, Tōru (2008), ‚Torukogo shijishi şu no tokuchō‛ *Characteristics of the Turkish demonstrative şu]. Tōkyō Daigaku Gengogaku Ronshū, 27: 217-232.
  16. HAYASI, Tōru (2009), ‚Torukogo shijishi no sentaku ni okeru washa no handan no baratsuki‛ *How variant are the judgments of Turkish speakers on the usage of demonstratives?]. Tōkyō Daigaku Gengogaku Ronshū, 28: 267-282.
  17. HAYASI, Tōru (2014), ‚Temporal characteristic of the Turkish demonstrative şu,‛ Turcology and Linguistics: Éva Ágnes Csató Festschrift, Nurettin Demir, Birsel Karakoç, Astrid Menz (Eds.). Ankara: Hacettepe Üniversitesi: 209-218.
  18. IINUMA, Eizō. (1995), Torukogo Kiso *Basic Turkish+, Tōkyō: Besutosha. IRMAK, Coşkun (2002),