Journals / Uluslararası İlişkiler / 2007 / Cilt: 4 - Sayı: 14

Does the War Against Iraq Constitute a "Crime of Aggression "? a Ruling of the House of Lords

Irak Savaşı Bir "Saldırı Suçu" mudur? İngiltere Lordlar Kamara'sının Bir Kararı

Pages
85–119
Publication Date
2022-11-05
DOI
—
🏛️Bibliographic metadata and full text access for this article are provided via DergiPark.
DergiPark Record ↗
✨

AI Summary & Key Takeaways

AI Insight
⚡ TL;DR(Too Long; Didn't Read)

The defendants asked the Law Lords to decide whether they should be allowed a necessity defense acknowledging the commission of a lesser crime as necessary to prevent the government of the United Kingdom (UK) from committing what they regarded as a far greater crime, a “crime of aggression.” The House of Lords decided that the crime of aggression is an international crime that is part of customary international law, but they refused to assess the legality of the decision by the UK government to launch the war, or to decide whether the war constituted a “crime against peace or war of aggression.” The Law Lords concluded that such questions were not for the courts to determine unless directed to do so by an act of Parliament.

📌 3 Key Takeaways

🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:This article analyzes a decision of House of Lords (February, 2006), the United Kingdom's highest court, concerned with anti-war demonstrations objecting on the basis of international law to British participation in the Iraq war.
📊
Key Findings & Data:This “civil disobedience” case alleged that the accused had unlawfully caused damage at military bases in England , as well as unlawfully trespassing on government property.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:The defendants asked the Law Lords to decide whether they should be allowed a necessity defense acknowledging the commission of a lesser crime as necessary to prevent the government of the United Kingdom (UK) from committing what they regarded as a far greater crime, a “crime of aggression.” The House of Lords decided that the crime of aggression is an international crime that is part of customary international law, but they refused to assess the legality of the decision by the UK government to launch the war, or to decide whether the war constituted a “crime against peace or war of aggression.” The Law Lords concluded that such questions were not for the courts to determine unless directed to do so by an act of Parliament.
🔬Design:Research Article
📍Scope:2006 Verileri
⚙️Variables:Domain Parameters

Abstract

This article analyzes a decision of House of Lords (February, 2006), the United Kingdom's highest court, concerned with anti-war demonstrations objecting on the basis of international law to British participation in the Iraq war. This “civil disobedience” case alleged that the accused had unlawfully caused damage at military bases in England , as well as unlawfully trespassing on government property. The defendants asked the Law Lords to decide whether they should be allowed a necessity defense acknowledging the commission of a lesser crime as necessary to prevent the government of the United Kingdom (UK) from committing what they regarded as a far greater crime, a “crime of aggression.” The House of Lords decided that the crime of aggression is an international crime that is part of customary international law, but they refused to assess the legality of the decision by the UK government to launch the war, or to decide whether the war constituted a “crime against peace or war of aggression.” The Law Lords concluded that such questions were not for the courts to determine unless directed to do so by an act of Parliament.

Özet

Bu makale İngiltere'deki savaş karşıtı grupların İngiltere hükümetinin Irak Savaşı'na katılımını protesto için düzenledikleri gösteriler nedeniyle gerçekleştirdikleri sivil itaatsizlik eylemleriyle ilgili olarak İngiltere'nin en yüksek mahkemesi sayılan Lordlar Kamarası'nın Şubat 2006 tarihinde vermiş olduğu kararı konu ediniyor. Sivil itaatsizlik suçu bazı askeri bölgelere izinsiz olarak girmek ve bu üslerdeki kamu mallarına zarar vermek şeklinde gerçekleşmiştir. Savunma makamı, mahkemeden, işlenen suçun İngiltere hükümetinin işlemekte olacağı daha önemli bir suçu, “saldırı suçu”nu önleme amacıyla gerçekleştirilmesi nedeniyle İngiltere ceza hukukundaki “zaruret hali” savunmasından yararlanma talebinde bulunmuştur. Lordlar Kamarası verdiği kararda saldırı suçunun uluslararası teamül (yapılageliş) hukukuna göre bir suç olduğunu kabul etmiş, ancak İngiltere hükümetinin Irak Savaşı'na katılma kararının yasallığını veya savaşın bir saldırı suçu sayılabileceği konusundaki irdelemeyi reddetmiştir. Hukuk Lordları'na gore, böyle bir karar, mahkemelerin değil, sadece Parlamento'nun yetkisi dahilindedir.

🔖

Cite This Article

ELVER, H. (2022). Does the War Against Iraq Constitute a "Crime of Aggression "? a Ruling of the House of Lords. Uluslararası İlişkiler, Cilt: 4 - Sayı: 14, 85–119. https://ajindex.com/articles/645116

📄 Full Text PDF Viewer

📄

PDF görüntüleyici hazırlanıyor...

References (17)

  1. Bassioni, M. Cheriff, 'The History of Universal Jurisdiction and Its Place in International Law", Steven Macedo (der.), Universal Jurisdiction: National Courts and Prosecution of Serious Crimes Under International Law, Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004.
  2. Bork, Robert, "Judicial Imperialism", Wall Street Journal, 22 Haziran 2003.
  3. Cryer, Robert, "Aggression at the Court of Appeal", Journal of Conflict and Security Law, Cilt 10, No 2, 2005.
  4. Falk, Richard, Gabriel Kolko ve Robert Jay Lifton (der.), 'The Question of War Crimes: A Statement of Perspective" Crimes of War, New York, Random House, 1971.
  5. Falk, Richard, Irene Genzier & Robert Jay Lifton (der.), Crimes of War: Iraq, New York, Nation Books, 2006.
  6. Falk, Richard, 'The Role of Civil Society Tribunals", Falk, Richard, Irene Genzier & Robert Jay Lifton (der.), Crimes of War: Iraq, New York, Nation Books, 2006.
  7. Ferencz, Benjamin B., "Crime of Aggression", Gabriella Kirk McDonald ve Olivia Swaak-Goldman (der.), Substantive and Procedural Aspects of International Criminal Law, Cilt I, Kluwer Publishing, 2000.
  8. Fisher-Lescano, Andreas, "Global Law v. Realpolitik: The Greman Complaint Against Donald Rumsfeld Concerning Torture in Abu Gharib". Franck, Thomas ve Gregory Fox (der.), International Law Decisions in National Courts, New York, Transnational Publisher, 1996.
  9. Frank, T.M., "What Happens Now' The United Nations After Iraq", American Journal of International Law, Cilt 97, No 3, 2003.
  10. Goldsmith, Jack ve Stephen Krasner, 'The limits of Idealism", Daedalus, Cilt 132, No 1, 2003.
  11. Gonzales, Alberto, "Memorandum for the President", 25 Ocak, 2002.
  12. Grossman, Mark, "US Foreign Policy and the ICC", 2002, http://www.sta-te.gov/p/9949pf.htm Guardian, 20 Şubat 2006. Jones & Milling [2005]
  13. Karan. Kirby, Michael, "Universal Jurisdiction and Judicial Reluctance: A New Fourteen Points", Steven Macedo (der.), Universal Jurisdiction: National Courts and Prosecution of Serious Crimes Under ^International Law, Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004.
  14. Kissinger, Henry, "The Pitfalls of Universal Jurisdiction" Foreign Affairs, Cilt 80, No 4, 2001.
  15. Lawrense, Frank, "The Nuremberg Principles: A Defense for Political Protesters", Hastibgs Law Journal, No 40, 1989.
  16. Oxman, Stephen A., "Comment: The Quest for Clarity", Steven Macedo (der.), Universal Jurisdiction: National Courts and Prosecution of Serious Crimes Under International Law, Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2004.
  17. Power, Colin, "