Review of “Osmanlı’da Bilginin Üretimi: Telvîh Haşiyelerinde Mukaddimât-ı Erba‘ Tartışmaları [Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ]” by İmam Rabbani Çelik
İmam Rabbani Çelik’in “Osmanlı’da Bilginin Üretimi: Telvîh Haşiyelerinde Mukaddimât-ı Erba‘ Tartışmaları” Adlı Eserinin Değerlendirmesi
A recent and notable revisionist monograph that challenges the dominant narrative shaped by these two presuppositions is Çelik’s Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ, published as part of ISAM’s “Second Classical Period Project.” Focusing on 15th-century Ottoman hāshiya literature, particularly the hāshiyas on the al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ (Four Premises) section of al-Taftāzānī’s al-Talwīḥ, one of the most influential texts of the post-classical period, this study critically examines the historical and scholarly significance, nature, character, and function of the hāshiya tradition and demonstrates how original knowledge was produced in hāshiya texts.
📌 3 Key Takeaways
🎯
Objective & Hypothesis:A recent and notable revisionist monograph that challenges the dominant narrative shaped by these two presuppositions is Çelik’s Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ, published as part of ISAM’s “Second Classical Period Project.” Focusing on 15th-century Ottoman hāshiya literature, particularly the hāshiyas on the al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ (Four Premises) section of al-Taftāzānī’s al-Talwīḥ, one of the most influential texts of the post-classical period, this study critically examines the historical and scholarly significance, nature, character, and function of the hāshiya tradition and demonstrates how original knowledge was produced in hāshiya texts.
📊
Key Findings & Data:A recent and notable revisionist monograph that challenges the dominant narrative shaped by these two presuppositions is Çelik’s Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ, published as part of ISAM’s “Second Classical Period Project.” Focusing on 15th-century Ottoman hāshiya literature, particularly the hāshiyas on the al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ (Four Premises) section of al-Taftāzānī’s al-Talwīḥ, one of the most influential texts of the post-classical period, this study critically examines the historical and scholarly significance, nature, character, and function of the hāshiya tradition and demonstrates how original knowledge was produced in hāshiya texts.
💡
Conclusion & Impact:A recent and notable revisionist monograph that challenges the dominant narrative shaped by these two presuppositions is Çelik’s Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ, published as part of ISAM’s “Second Classical Period Project.” Focusing on 15th-century Ottoman hāshiya literature, particularly the hāshiyas on the al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ (Four Premises) section of al-Taftāzānī’s al-Talwīḥ, one of the most influential texts of the post-classical period, this study critically examines the historical and scholarly significance, nature, character, and function of the hāshiya tradition and demonstrates how original knowledge was produced in hāshiya texts.
🔬Design:Kitap İncelemesi
📍Scope:Comprehensive Sample
⚙️Variables:Osmanlı · Haşiye · Bilgi
Abstract
A recent and notable revisionist monograph that challenges the dominant narrative shaped by these two presuppositions is Çelik’s Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ, published as part of ISAM’s “Second Classical Period Project.” Focusing on 15th-century Ottoman hāshiya literature, particularly the hāshiyas on the al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ (Four Premises) section of al-Taftāzānī’s al-Talwīḥ, one of the most influential texts of the post-classical period, this study critically examines the historical and scholarly significance, nature, character, and function of the hāshiya tradition and demonstrates how original knowledge was produced in hāshiya texts.
Ekşici, A. Y. (2026). Review of “Osmanlı’da Bilginin Üretimi: Telvîh Haşiyelerinde Mukaddimât-ı Erba‘ Tartışmaları [Knowledge Production in the Ottoman Empire: Discussions on al-Muqaddimāt al-arba‘ in the Super-commentaries of al-Talwīḥ]” by İmam Rabbani Çelik. İslam Tetkikleri Dergisi, Cilt: 16 Sayı: 2, 505–510. https://ajindex.com/articles/1668793